CONFERENCE COMMITTEE ON SB 160

 

May 21, 2001                                                                                                          Hearing Room B

4:00 PM                                                                                                                           Tapes 1 – 2

 

MEMBERS PRESENT:         Sen. Charles Starr, Chair

                                                Sen. Peter Courtney

                                                Sen. Ted Ferrioli

                                                Rep. Vic Backlund

                                                Rep. Bill Morrisette

                                                Rep. Tootie Smith

 

STAFF PRESENT:                 Jan McComb, Committee Administrator

Patrick Brennan, Committee Assistant

 

MEASURE/ISSUES HEARD:           SB 160B Work Session

 

These minutes are in compliance with Senate and House Rules.  Only text enclosed in quotation marks reports a speaker’s exact words.  For complete contents, please refer to the tapes.

 

TAPE/#

Speaker

Comments

TAPE 1, A

004

Chair Starr

Calls the committee to order at 4: p.m. and opens a work session on  SB 160B.

SB 160B WORK SESSION

009

Jan McComb

Committee Administrator.  Provides a brief explanation of SB 160.  Describes the differences between the House and Senate versions of the bill, specifically whether chiropractors should be allowed to perform examinations required for participation in interscholastic athletic activities.  Indicates that the –B9 amendments (EXHIBIT A), and        –B10 amendments (EXHIBIT B) have been submitted for the committee’s consideration.

022

Sen. Ferrioli

Indicates that the language related to chiropractic physicians was inserted at his request.  Expresses support to the –B10 amendments, adding that he believes an additional conceptual amendment is necessary.  Suggests that chiropractors may not be qualified to perform diagnosis related to cardiopulmonary health.  Says he would prefer that chiropractors be allowed to perform examinations in areas in which they have training and experience.

044

Rep. Morrisette

Asks whether chiropractors receive training that qualifies them to perform diagnostics.

050

Sen. Ferrioli

Describes the types of diagnostics used to determine whether a youth is ready to participate in a sport or athletic activity. Says the examinations are not invasive, but are related to general health, skeletal alignment and musculature. 

063

Rep. Morrisette

Requests an explanation of why some chiropractors might be qualified to perform diagnostics while others may not be.

071

John Sanscom

Offers as an example a description of the diagnostic process for Marfan Syndrome, a genetic defect associated to laxity in the skin and connective tissues that is often found within individuals who have unusually long legs and arms. Says Marfan Syndrome is sometimes associated with cardiopulmonary difficulties such as heart valve problems.  Indicates that the diagnostic process for Marfan Syndrom is problematic.

090

Rep. Morrisette

Asks whether chiropractors are trained to diagnose Marfan Syndrome.

092

Sanscom

Replies he does not know, adding that most physicians are trained to do so.

095

Rep. Morrisette

Asks whether nurses and physician assistants are qualified to make this type of diagnosis.

098

Sanscom

Replies affirmatively.

100

Larry Harvey

Oregon Chiropractors Association.  Refers to testimony at a previous hearing that indicated that the academic preparedness for doctors and chiropractors is nearly identical, with the primary differences being related to physicians.  Says that the solution is to ensure that the Oregon Board of Chiropractic Examiners (OBCE) shall make rules determining how training will be provided for these types of examinations.

133

Jim Anderson

Oregon Medical Association (OMA).  States that an examination of the curriculum for chiropractic preparation indicates there is no training related to the diagnostic skills necessary to detect, treat, or diagnose cardiopulmonary problems. 

145

Sanscom

Emphasizes that detection of cardiopulmonary problems is the most difficult part of the diagnostic process because they often present themselves in a subtle manner.  Remarks that physicians listen to patient’s hearts daily as part of their diagnostic procedure, and that the experience thus gained provides the critical tools to pick up subtle findings.  Asserts that chiropractors are unlikely to gain the experiential skills in detecting cardiopulmonary problems even if they receive the requisite education. Reiterates that the goal is to protect student athletes from catastrophic injuries or health problems.  Concedes that not all such occurrences may be preventable but that students should be given the best chance possible.

183

Rep. Morrisette

Asks whether physician assistants and nurses have the experiential skills to detect cardiopulmonary irregularities.

187

Sanscom

Answers affirmatively, as they perform heart examinations daily.

197

Sen. Ferrioli

Says the discussion illustrates his point, which is that whether an abnormality is detected by a physician assistant, nurse, or chiropractor, the end result will be a referral to a physician for diagnosis.  Remarks that the person discovering the problem during the screening process need not treat the abnormality, as the goal is simply to detect the problem before it can result in a catastrophic injury.

229

Harvey

Concurs with Sen. Ferrioli.  Mentions that even his personal doctor may not qualify to give a sports examination should the bill be passed in its current form.  Asserts that those performing the examinations need not be trained to provide treatment.  Suggests the issue is becoming a “turf battle” between physicians and chiropractors.  Recalls that one student who had been found to have a defect was allowed to play anyway by his parents and died. 

266

Rep. Morrisette

Asks again what qualifies chiropractors to make diagnoses of heart ailments.

275

Chair Starr

Recalls compelling testimony during previous hearings that chiropractors are qualified to make such diagnoses.

280

Sen. Ferrioli

Opines that the verbiage used in the –B10 amendments suggest that nurses and physician assistants are capable of making a diagnosis, which is not the case. Asserts that a more accurate word would be “detection” rather than diagnosis. Asserts that the purpose of the bill is to detect ailments and report them to parents.

308

Rep. Smith

Suggests that the –B10 amendments create questions about whether some small towns in her district will have anyone qualified to make a diagnosis of a cardiopulmonary ailment.  Posits that if the language is too tight then whoever performs the exams could be open to liability.  Agrees with Sen. Ferrioli that detection and diagnosis are different.  Remarks that there are not many cardiologists in Molalla. 

341

Rep. Backlund

Solicits opinions regarding replacing the word “detection” with the word “diagnosis.”

351

Sanscom

Submits that there is little difference, as anyone not qualified to treat an ailment will doubtless refer the problem to someone who can.  Emphasizes the need to ensure that children receiving the exams are in the hands of someone who will be able to find any problems that may exist.  Reiterates that chiropractic training does not prepare one to detect cardiopulmonary abnormalities and that coursework cannot replace experience. 

402

Harvey

Requests clarification as to the suggested language proposed by Rep. Backlund.  Says chiropractors would not have a problem performing the physical examination.  Asserts that the bill was not specifically designed to address heart disease, but rather to seek a solution to a string unfortunate occurrences that have occurred on the field of play.

TAPE 2, A

016

Anderson

Indicates he does not object to changing “diagnose” to “detect.”  Wonders whether the committee is confident that chiropractors are qualified to detect potentially dangerous heart ailments.

033

Sen. Courtney

Notes that there is already a form and protocol developed for the examinations, such as type and frequency, and stresses the need to make that form and protocol consistent across the state. Asks whether form and protocol dictate the answer the question at hand. 

048

Anderson

Responds that form and protocol are two different things.  Describes the difference between form and protocol. 

067

Sen. Courtney

Says that form and protocol are germane to the discussion insofar as they relate to the examinations performed on student athletes. 

078

Anderson

Mentions that there is a doctor on the Oregon State Activities Association (OSAA) Committee who helped to develop the form and protocol for the exams. 

085

Sanscom

Agrees that form and protocol are important, but so are the quality and experience of the person performing the examination. 

098

Sen. Courtney

Asks who should be making the final decision whether or not a student participates in athletic activity.

107

Sanscom

Disagrees with the assertion that few people are qualified to perform the diagnosis as it is written in the bill, as general practitioners perform such examinations daily.  Says that pre-participation examinations can do little to prevent catastrophic on-field injury, but can be very effective at preventing cardiopulmonary failure. 

147

Rep. Morrisette

Requests an explanation of the current rule and why it is necessary to change it

151

Harvey

Explains that parents make the initial determination as to whether a student may participate by signing a consent form, with a coach making subsequent determinations based upon the talent of the student. Indicates that chiropractors are already signing off on consent forms because there are an insufficient number of doctors in many small communities throughout the state. Says the –B10 amendments are consistent with current practice. 

180

Rep. Morrisette

Wonders whether chiropractors would be placed at the bottom of the list of health care providers to consult for athletic examinations.

185

Harvey

Replies that the bill does not prioritize providers in that way.

190

Rep. Morrisette

Asks whether the bill merely legitimizes current practice and whether the removal of chiropractors could create a hardship for some small communities.

196

Sen. Ferrioli

Draws an analogy between how chiropractors can detect anomalies and how dentists and optometrists often discover ailments unrelated to their examinations and for which they are not trained to diagnose.  Says the distinction is primarily one of education, practice, and scope of examination.  Submits that chiropractors spend their days examining and treating patients for physical ailments, albeit in different manner than traditional doctors.  Reiterates that if chiropractors cannot demonstrate competence in detecting cardiopulmonary defects they will not be allowed to perform the examinations.  Says the burden of proof of competence will be on the physician. 

265

Chair Starr

Mentions that the conference committee was required in order to consider the training of chiropractic physicians.  Opines that it is appropriate for the training requirement be part of the bill. 

304

Rep. Backlund

MOTION:  Moves to AMEND SB 160B on page 1, in line 17, after "physician", insert "who has clinical training and experience in detecting cardiopulmonary diseases and defects".

324

Sen. Ferrioli

Restates the motion.

333

Rep. Morrisette

Concurs with the conceptual amendments.  Acknowledges the validity of the points raised related to detection.  Says he is concerned that prohibition against chiropractors performing examinations could hinder some smaller communities.  Agrees that most chiropractors are less able to detect heart ailments and expresses hope that general practitioners will be the first choice for exams.

364

 

VOTE:  5-1

AYE:            5 - Backlund, Ferrioli, Morrisette, T. Smith, Starr

NAY:            1 - Courtney

 

Chair Starr

The motion Carries.

370

Sen. Ferrioli

MOTION:  Moves SB 160B to the floor with the recommendation that the Senate CONCUR in House amendments and that the bill be FURTHER AMENDED by the –B10 amendments as conceptually amended and be repassed.

286

Sen. Courtney

Notes that the amended bill applies only to public schools, despite the fact that private schools compete and practice against public schools within the OSAA.  Suggests that conceptually amending the bill to strike the word “district” would allow the bill to apply to private schools as well.  Emphasizes the need to protect students in both private and public schools.

TAPE 1, B

019

Sen. Ferrioli

Restates and clarifies the motion.

023

 

VOTE:  6-0

AYE:            6 - Backlund, Courtney, Ferrioli, Morrisette,

                           T. Smith, Starr

 

Chair Starr

The motion Carries.

026

Sen. Ferrioli

Asserts that the burden of proof of competence rests on the shoulders of the physician, nurse, physician assistant, or chiropractor who is to perform the examination. 

037

Rep. Morrisette

Questions whether there is sufficient legislative intent.

039

Sen. Ferrioli

Asserts that the bill provides sufficient legislative intent.

040

Chair Starr

Adjourns the conference committee at 5:05 p.m.

 

Submitted By,                                                                           Reviewed By,

 

 

 

Patrick Brennan,                                                                       Jan McComb,

Committee Assistant                                                                 Committee Administrator

 

EXHIBIT SUMMARY

 

A – SB 160B, -B9 amendments, Rep. Phil Barnhart, 1 p.

B – SB 160B, -B10 amendments, staff, 1 p.