HOUSE COMMITTEE ON JUDICIARY
January 29, 2003 Hearing Room 357
1:00 p.m. Tapes 19 - 20
MEMBERS PRESENT: Rep. Max Williams, Chair
Rep. Robert Ackerman, Vice-Chair
Rep. Gordon Anderson, Vice-Chair
Rep. Jeff Barker
Rep. Jerry Krummel
Rep. Greg Macpherson
Rep. Floyd Prozanski
Rep. Lane Shetterly
MEMBER EXCUSED: Rep. Bob Jenson
GUEST MEMBER: Rep.
Steve March
STAFF PRESENT: Bill
Taylor, Counsel
Ann Martin, Committee Assistant
MEASURE/ISSUES HEARD: Informational Meeting:
“People with Mental Illness in Our
Criminal Justice System”
These minutes are in
compliance with Senate and House Rules.
Only text enclosed in quotation marks reports a speaker’s exact
words. For complete contents,
please refer to the tapes.
|
TAPE/# |
Speaker |
Comments |
|
Tape 19, A |
||
|
004 |
Chair
Williams |
Calls
the meeting to order at 1:10 p.m. |
|
015 |
Bill
Taylor |
Committee
Counsel. Informs committee of presentation. |
|
INFORMATIONAL MEETING—People with
Mental Illness in Our Criminal Justice System |
||
|
020 |
Daniel
Souweine |
Council
of State Governments. Submits testimony, introduces panel and announces the presentation
on mental illness and the criminal justice system (EXHIBITS A-C). |
|
065 |
Fred
Osher, M.D. |
Director,
Center of Behavioral Health, Justice & Public Policy. Discusses Mental
Illness and the Criminal Justice System. |
|
258 |
Captain
John Caceci |
Monroe
County Sheriff’s Office, New York. Submits testimony and talks about The
Criminal Justice System and Mentally Ill Offenders (EXHIBIT D). |
|
TAPE 20, A |
||
|
002 |
Caceci |
Continues
his discussion on mentally ill offenders. |
|
029 |
Osher |
Explains
lessons from the Mental Health Consensus Project. |
|
090 |
David
Wertheimer |
Principal
Consultant, Kelly Point Partners. Submits testimony and talks about measuring
dollars and cents and the price tags related to the incarceration of people
with severe and persistent mental illnesses (EXHIBIT E). |
|
158 |
Chair
Williams |
Asks
about the two studies and if they were long-term or short-term studies. |
|
155 |
Osher |
Replies
that this was a 1-year study or short-term study. |
|
182 |
Wertheimer |
Continues
his discussion on Cost Data Studies. |
|
383 |
Osher |
Comments
on what the legislature can do about mental illness and the criminal justice
system. |
|
TAPE 19, B |
||
|
010 |
Osher |
Continues
his discussion. |
|
058 |
Wertheimer |
Discusses
silo busting in Washington State. |
|
119 |
Rep.
Prozanski |
Asks
about the pilot project in Washington. |
|
126 |
Wertheimer |
Responds
that the initial pilot project was in King County, but now encompasses all
Washington counties. |
|
140 |
Rep.
Prozanski |
Wonders
how the pilot project works with the counties. |
|
145 |
Wertheimer |
Explains
how Washington’s mental health dollar allocations are based on regional
support networks. |
|
175 |
Chair
Williams |
Asks
about housing and re-entry issues. Asks if the King County project was a
controlled housing environment. |
|
190 |
Wertheimer |
Answers
that initially it was a controlled environment. |
|
204 |
Osher |
Discusses
predictors of recidivism and the importance of housing for people coming out
of jails and prisons. |
|
264 |
Rep.
Shetterly |
Comments
on how prevention and transition of offenders back into the community is most
cost effective. Asks about the McNeil Island project. |
|
288 |
Wertheimer |
Explains
the Partnership for Community Safety pilot project. |
|
TAPE 20, B |
||
|
005 |
Caceci |
Stresses
the importance of community-based
treatment programs and housing for mentally ill offenders. |
|
052 |
Rep.
Anderson |
Mentions
success of mentors at youth authority facilities in his area. Asks if there
are any mentor programs for adult offenders. |
|
064 |
Wertheimer |
Says,
yes, and discusses a program in King County. |
|
081 |
Osher |
Emphasizes
that case managers are very important for coordinating service needs for
mentally ill offenders returning to society. |
|
096 |
Rep.
Anderson |
Asks
about the importance of psychotropic drugs for these offenders. |
|
103 |
Osher |
Says
that medication is very helpful to the seriously mentally ill offenders. |
|
114 |
Souweine |
Comments
that there has been much success in peers assisting people with mental
illnesses. |
|
125 |
Wertheimer |
Discusses
a program in Connecticut. |
|
141 |
Chair
Williams |
Mentions
that access to antipsychotic medications usually requires access to a health
care program. |
|
143 |
Rep.
March |
Asks
if there are any statutory changes to involuntary commitment that they would
suggest. |
|
154 |
Osher |
Says
that is an area where there isn’t consensus. |
|
164 |
Rep.
Prozanski |
Talks
about a pilot program in Lane County that prepares offenders for re-entering
society. |
|
181 |
Osher |
Says
that he has been connected with many providers in Oregon and that there have
been many good programs in Oregon. |
|
196 |
Rep.
Shetterly |
Asks
if there is consensus on psychotropic drugs. |
|
204 |
Osher |
Answers
that there is little debate on the effectiveness of these drugs, but that
there is a breakdown in compliance issues. |
|
219 |
Rep.
Macpherson |
Wonders
about housing issues for the mentally ill offenders re-entering society. |
|
235 |
Osher |
Says
that this issue has been understudied and explains. |
|
263 |
Wertheimer |
Comments
on housing issues. Says that cluster housing for returning sex offenders
reduces recidivism, but frightens the public. |
|
300 |
Taylor |
Discusses
next week’s schedule. |
|
383 |
Chair
Williams |
Adjourns
the meeting at 2:55 p.m. |
EXHIBIT
SUMMARY
A
– Informational, Mental Illness and the Criminal Justice System, submitted by
Daniel Souweine, 43 pgs.
B
– Informational, Presenter biographies, submitted by Daniel Souweine, 2 pgs.
C
– Informational, Booklet, Criminal Justice/Mental Health Consensus
Project/Project Overview, submitted by Daniel Souweine, 9 pgs.
D
– Informational, Written presentation on The Criminal Justice System and
Mentally Ill Offenders, submitted by Captain John Caceci, dated January 29,
2003, 9 pgs.
E
– Informational, Written material on People with Mental Illness in the Criminal
Justice System: Fiscal Implications, submitted by David Wertheimer, 2 pgs.