SENATE COMMITTEE ON HEALTH POLICY
January 19, 2005 Hearing Room B
1:00 PM Tapes 2 - 3
MEMBERS PRESENT: Sen. Laurie Monnes Anderson, Chair
Sen. Peter Courtney
Sen. Bill Morrisette
MEMBER EXCUSED: Sen. Jeff Kruse, Vice-Chair
Sen. Gary George
STAFF PRESENT: Rick Berkobien, Committee Administrator
Brittany Kenison, Committee Assistant
MEASURES/ISSUES HEARD & WITNESSES:
Report on Governor’s Mental Health Task Force
Oregon State Hospital Master Plan
Bob Nikkel, Department of Human Services, Office of Mental Health and Addiction Service
Gina Firman, Association of Oregon Community Mental Health Programs
These minutes are in compliance with Senate and House Rules. Only text enclosed in quotation marks reports a speaker’s exact words. For complete contents, please refer to the tapes.
|
TAPE/# |
Speaker |
Comments |
|
TAPE 2, A |
||
|
003 |
Chair Monnes Anderson |
Calls the committee to order at 1:02 PM. Chairs opens informational meeting. |
|
GOVERNOR’S MENTAL HEALTH TASK FORCE, INFORMATIONAL MEETING |
||
|
005 |
Chair Monnes Anderson |
Gives overview of Agenda. Announces that Barry Kast, Department of Human Services, Health Services, will not be available for the meeting. Invites Bob Nikkel, Department of Human Services, Office of Mental Health and Addition Service. |
|
015 |
Bob Nikkel |
Introduces himself and presents overview of speech. Submits written testimony (EXHIBIT A). |
|
030 |
Chair Monnes Anderson |
Invites Gina Firman, Association of Oregon Community Mental Health Programs to witness table to join Nikkel |
|
035 |
Chair Monnes Anderson |
Excuses Sen. George and Sen. Kruse. |
|
040 |
Nikkel |
Presents overview of mental health history in Oregon. |
|
090 |
Sen. Morrisette |
Requests information for background (history) information. |
|
100 |
Nikkel |
Agrees to request. Reviews graph of Psychiatric Hospitalization Rate. |
|
110 |
Sen. Courtney |
Asks Nikkel to clarify if the graph is based on forensic, civil or both. |
|
115 |
Nikkel |
Advises that graph contains both forensic and civil hospitals |
|
130 |
Nikkel |
Continues to review graph for Psychiatric Hospitalization. Presents pie graph of Funds for Department of Humans Services, Office of Mental Health and Addiction Services. |
|
145 |
Chair Monnes Anderson |
Asks Nikkel for number of mental health patients are being served in state hospital and how many are in community mental health. |
|
150 |
Nikkel |
Estimates that in 2003-2005, a total of 120,000 people were served in the mental health system. Of that 1,500 have been served in the state hospital. |
|
160 |
Chair Monnes Anderson |
Asks of 1500 in hospital, how many could be served in the community. |
|
165 |
Nikkel |
Believes that most people could be served in the community. |
|
170 |
Sen. Courtney |
Clarifies that the 120,000 does not include the number of mentally ill people who are in the prison system. |
|
180 |
Nikkel |
Affirms and refers to graph in exhibit. |
|
195 |
Sen. Morrisette |
Asks Nikkel to clarify that there are mentally ill people in jail and if they are there purposely. |
|
200 |
Nikkel |
Affirms and believes that it is a policy question to be asked. |
|
210 |
Nikkel |
Summarizes history for community mental health programs. |
|
240 |
Nikkel |
Reports on services and facilities in today’s current condition and comments on services alternative and refers to General Adult Beds Before and After Restructuring. |
|
265 |
Nikkel |
Comments on medications and effects since the 1960’s. |
|
285 |
Nikkel |
Summarizes background of people with mental illness and the connection of drug and alcohol use. |
|
300 |
Sen. Morrisette |
Comments on Alcohol Recovery fee bill in the process and hopes that it could be used for mental health programs using statistics. |
|
315 |
Nikkel |
Adds that 60 to 70 percent of the acute care psychiatric admissions have drug and alcohol involved in addition to the mental illness symptoms. Also shares other studies performed in other states. |
|
335 |
Nikkel |
Describes cost of housing trends in 1980’s and 1990’s. Explains areas that the mentally ill struggle with. |
|
355 |
Sen. Morrisette |
Asks for the number foster homes for the mentally ill in the state of Oregon. |
|
360 |
Nikkel |
Affirms that there are several hundred. |
|
370 |
Gina Firman |
Association of Oregon Community Mental Health Programs. Explains that there are Adult Foster homes and that insurance is a problem area and it is expensive. |
|
380 |
Sen. Morrisette |
Clarifies that he was talking about liability insurance for the homeowners. |
|
383 |
Firman |
Remarks that it is a problem and that it is expensive. |
|
385 |
Sen. Morrisette |
Comments that something needs to be done to keep the homes open. |
|
387 |
Nikkel |
Adds that it is an issue that it is being addressed, but no solution yet. |
|
390 |
Chair Monnes Anderson |
Remarks that there will be a bill regarding the homeowners insurance going to Sen. Morrisette’s human service committee. |
|
400 |
Firman |
Adds that during 2003 session about a bill addressing the homeowners issue did not pass. |
|
405 |
Rick Berkobien |
Committee Administrator. Ask if Nikkel if forensic type cases be served in a more localized program and what kind of funding would be involved. |
|
425 |
Nikkel |
Believes that they could, but cost would rise considerably. |
|
450 |
Nikkel |
Comments on SB 267 passed in 2003 and positive effects. Training issues and workforce issues need to be addressed. Believes in evidence based practice movement. |
|
475 |
Nikkel |
Comments on reliance on Medicaid federal money from the community mental health system. Remarks on how little the state hospital uses this money. The Oregon Health Plan has been a step forward in the reduction of stigma of mental health treatments. |
|
TAPE 3, A |
||
|
045 |
Nikkel |
Gives overview of issues that need to be addressed: · Struggle with increased number of mentally ill people in the prison system. · Continue with evidence based practice and train toward this. · Balance needs with budget realities. · Balance public safety and civil rights. · Be more prepared to respond to changing demographics. |
|
070 |
Nikkel |
Reviews chart for Mental Health Funding. |
|
145 |
Nikkel |
Summarizes and concludes. |
|
147 |
Sen. Morrisette |
Comments on Scar Jasper Mountain facility for children and its background. |
|
155 |
Chair Monnes Anderson |
Refers to the Mental Health Funding chart and if it includes all fund dollars. |
|
165 |
Nikkel |
Confirms that it includes all fund monies. |
|
180 |
Sen. Morrisette |
Requests list of child treatment centers within Oregon. Requests clarification about classification and the concerns. |
|
190 |
Nikkel |
Responds that most people feel that they are right level. |
|
195 |
Berkobien |
Wants to know what percentage of OHP program funding includes Medicaid monies. |
|
205 |
Nikkel |
Defers to Firman. |
|
215 |
Firman |
Answers that many patients are OHP eligible and rely on Medicaid to fund program. |
|
225 |
Sen. Morrisette |
Asks if there is anyway to track everyone who falls out of the system and what happens to them. |
|
235 |
Nikkel |
Comments that they could track now with today’s technology. Says that it is harder to find them once they drop out of the system. |
|
250 |
Chair Monnes Anderson |
Remarks that Medicaid doesn’t match money to the state hospital like it does to the community mental health, so could they contract with the other hospitals to add small units of psychiatric housing so Medicaid could match the sixty cents to each of the states thirty cents. |
|
260 |
Nikkel |
Explains that it has been done for the last 10 years. Adds that there are 23 beds in Salem hospital and are eligible for Medicaid. Presents the issue of number of patients in the state hospital who are ready to be discharged and go to smaller facilities within the community. |
|
285 |
Chair Monnes Anderson |
Wants to know if there has been progress. |
|
290 |
Nikkel |
Responds that there has been progress, but new facilities are needed as people are waiting in the state hospital. |
|
295 |
Chair Monnes Anderson |
Asks Nikkel if he has access to the number of patients that have been placed into the communities and the new siding that have happened in the last two years. |
|
397 |
Nikkel |
Offers to return information to the committee. |
|
300 |
Sen. Morrisette |
Asks about model in Josephine County. |
|
305 |
Firman |
Addresses Chair Monnes Andersons question, and believes that 278 new community placements. Describes resolution centers open which help state hospitals. |
|
325 |
Sen. Morrisette |
Asks for name of county representative. |
|
327 |
Firman |
Responds that his name is Bob Beckett, who is now working for non profit organization. |
|
330 |
Sen. Morrisette |
Asks if there were any forensic patients in Josephine County facility. |
|
335 |
Nikkel |
Answers yes. |
|
345 |
Nikkel |
Moves on to the overview of the systemic problems in the public mental health system. |
|
TAPE 2, B |
||
|
010 |
Nikkel |
Continues discussing the systemic problems in the public mental health system. |
|
020 |
Chair Monnes Anderson |
Stands at ease due to fire drill. |
|
035 |
Nikkel |
Continues discussing the systemic problems in the public mental health system. |
|
050 |
Chair Monnes Anderson |
Clarifies statement on exhibit that states far less money is spent on children than adults. |
|
055 |
Nikkel |
Explains that more adults are hospitalized under the state hospital than children. Begins to discuss parity. |
|
060 |
Chair Monnes Anderson |
Comments that discussions will be held next week on mental health parity. |
|
061 |
Sen. Morrisette |
Comments on problem in identifying mental illness in children and asks if it is still a problem. |
|
070 |
Nikkel |
Confirms that it is and identifies reasons and solutions. |
|
075 |
Nikkel |
Continues to summarize the systemic problems in the public mental health system. |
|
090 |
Firman |
Comments on evidence based practices. |
|
105 |
Firman |
Introduces budget comparison chart for written testimony (EXHIBIT B) and reviews. |
|
165 |
Sen. Morrisette |
Wants to know if county funding issue has been corrected. |
|
125 |
Nikkel |
Says that the issue is in the process of being corrected |
|
130 |
Sen. Morrisette |
Wants to know if equity with Washington, Multnomah and Clackamas counties have been solved. |
|
135 |
Nikkel |
Comments on making progress in the counties. |
|
145 |
Sen. Morrisette |
Asks if Washington county is happy. |
|
150 |
Firman |
Explains counties have had a discussion about equity and pleased with progress. |
|
157 |
Sen. Morrisette |
Asks if Clackamas county has dropped out. |
|
160 |
Firman |
Responds no. |
|
165 |
Sen. Morrisette |
Comments on background of issue and the current progress. |
|
177 |
Chair Monnes Anderson |
Asks to confirm that Multnomah county is not participating. |
|
179 |
Firman |
Affirms. |
|
170 |
Sen. Morrisette |
Asks if Multnomah county has the ability to serve people who move to the area as they are required to. |
|
172 |
Firman |
Explains that urban drift wasn’t as significant as they thought. Suggests that Multnomah be invited for testimony. |
|
180 |
Chair Monnes Anderson |
Agrees and will invite the county for testimony. |
|
190 |
Nikkel |
Comments on center for mental health services formula to determine the number of people moving to urban area. |
|
195 |
Sen. Courtney |
Ask how much a mental health parity in Oregon would play into the funding issue. |
|
215 |
Nikkel |
Does not think that it will have an effect on funding in his opinion. Would help elevate on some stress on public mental health system. |
|
225 |
Sen. Courtney |
Comments on attention for children versus adult health care. Asks if there is an “attitude” in the ways children are treated versus adults in the mental health system. |
|
240 |
Nikkel |
Replies that he found where in some counties, some of the money for children services has been spent on adult care. In process of working with these counties. |
|
257 |
Sen. Courtney |
Asks if audit will be performed. |
|
260 |
Nikkel |
Answers that he has reviewed data, but has not called for an audit. |
|
268 |
Sen. Courtney |
Asks Nikkel what he calls the procedure if it is not called an audit. |
|
270 |
Nikkel |
Explains that it is not a requirement that children’s funding be spent on children services, but working to change that. |
|
275 |
Chair Monnes Anderson |
Recognizes need for audit. |
|
280 |
Firman |
Comments on successfulness on county and state working together on accountability. |
|
OREGON STATE HOSPITAL MASTER PLAN |
||
|
300 |
Nikkel |
Refers to OSH Master Plan and reviews (EXHIBIT C). · Reviews statement of work and process. |
|
355 |
Sen. Morrisette |
Asks Nikkel what PSRB stand for. |
|
360 |
Nikkel |
Psychiatric Security Review Board (PSRB). |
|
370 |
Chair Monnes Anderson |
Asks if adjudications increase is from alcohol and drug involvement. |
|
375 |
Nikkel |
Speculates that increase in mental health is from drugs. Discusses approaches. |
|
390 |
Sen. Morrisette |
Asks what the PSRB does. |
|
400 |
Nikkel |
Explains that it was enacted in 1977 to help in sending people with mental illness to treatment centers instead of sending to correctional system. |
|
405 |
Nikkel |
Gives background on Oregon State Hospital (OSH) Master Plan and dates for contract review process. |
|
430 |
Nikkel |
Continues to review OSH Master Plan
|
|
TAPE 3, B |
||
|
005 |
Nikkel |
Continues to review OSH Master Plan |
|
025 |
Chair Monnes Anderson |
In reference to Measure 11, asks whether funds for building a prison could instead be used to build a prison/mental health center. |
|
030 |
Nikkel |
Defers question to Department of Corrections. |
|
035 |
Sen. Courtney |
Refers to page 4. Comments on task and the huge effort involved and the report. |
|
055 |
Nikkel |
Comments that it will be part of the stake holders process during phase one. |
|
065 |
Nikkel |
Gives overview of improvements. |
|
115 |
Nikkel |
Summarizes and concludes. |
|
130 |
Chair Monnes Anderson |
Comments on issues and concludes. Closes informational meeting. Adjourns meeting at 2:50 PM. |
EXHIBIT SUMMARY
A. Governor’s Mental Health Task Force, written testimony, Bob Nikkel, 7 pp
B. Governor’s Mental Health Task Force, chart, Gina Firman, 1 p
C. Oregon State Hospital Master Plan Project, staff, 15 pp