SENATE COMMITTEE ON JUDICIARY
March 14, 2005 Hearing Room 343
1:00 P.M. Tapes 64 - 65
Corrected 10/26/05
MEMBERS PRESENT: Sen. Ginny Burdick, Chair
Sen. Charles Starr, Vice-Chair
Sen. Roger Beyer
Sen. Floyd Prozanski
Sen. Charlie Ringo
Sen. Vicki Walker
Sen. Doug Whitsett
STAFF PRESENT: Joe O'Leary, Counsel
William E. Taylor, Counsel
Dale Penn, Committee Assistant
MEASURES/ISSUES HEARD:
SB 493 – Public Hearing
SB 229 – Work Session
SB 234 – Work Session
HB 2261 – Public Hearing and Work Session
SB 492 – Public Hearing
SB 591 – Public Hearing
SB 938 – Public Hearing
SB 230 – Work Session
SB 921 – Work Session
SB 238 – Work Session
SB 239 – Work Session
These minutes are in compliance with Senate and House Rules. Only text enclosed in quotation marks reports a speaker’s exact words. For complete contents, please refer to the tapes.
|
TAPE/# |
Speaker |
Comments |
|
TAPE 64, A |
||
|
003 |
Chair Burdick |
Calls the meeting to order at 1:15 p.m. and opens a public hearing on SB 493. |
|
SB 493 – PUBLIC HEARING |
||
|
010 |
Joe O’Leary |
Counsel. Describes SB 493 relating to lawfully using a bicycle lane to proceed through a red light at the top of a T intersection after stopping at a light. Introduces the -1 amendment (EXHIBIT H). |
|
046 |
Daniel J. Heffernan |
Citizen. Submits a PowerPoint presentation and testimony and testifies in support of SB 493 (EXHIBITS A & B). |
|
090 |
Heffernan |
Emphasizes the ridiculous nature of forcing a cyclist to stop at such an intersection. |
|
127 |
Chair Burdick |
Inquires about mopeds and motorized wheelchairs under this law. |
|
134 |
Heffernan |
States that wheelchairs are allowed, but mopeds are not. |
|
144 |
Heffernan |
Goes over the PowerPoint presentation (Exhibit A). |
|
169 |
Sen. Beyer |
Asks about the yield for a cyclist in a certain scenario. |
|
173 |
Heffernan |
Responds with information on who has the right of way. |
|
195 |
Scott Bricker |
Policy Director, Bicycle Transportation Alliance. Submits testimony and testifies in a neutral stance on SB 493 (EXHIBIT C). |
|
235 |
John Jackley |
Executive Officer, Highway Division, Department of Transportation. Submits testimony and testifies in a neutral stance on SB 493 (EXHIBIT D). |
|
257 |
Chair Burdick |
Closes the public hearing on SB 493 and opens a work session on SB 229 and SB 234. |
|
SB 229 & SB 234 – WORK SESSION |
||
|
265 |
Chair Burdick |
Moves SB 229 & SB 234 to the agenda for March 15, 2005. |
|
272 |
Chair Burdick |
Calls the senate judiciary committee to recess. |
|
274 |
Chair Burdick |
Calls the meeting to order and opens a public hearing on HB 2261. |
|
HB 2261 – PUBLIC HEARING |
||
|
276 |
Joe O’Leary |
Counsel. Describes HB 2261 relating to nonsubstantive and technical changes in Oregon law. |
|
283 |
Dave Heynderickx |
Acting Legislative Counsel. Testifies on the reasoning behind SB 2261; a housekeeping bill. |
|
330 |
Heynderickx |
Discusses the comments on each change in the bill, and talks about the -1 amendment (EXHIBIT E). |
|
391 |
Chair Burdick |
Closes the public hearing on HB 2261 and opens a work session on HB 2261. |
|
HB 2261 – WORK SESSION |
||
|
402 |
Sen. Starr |
MOTION: Moves to ADOPT HB 2261-1 amendments dated 2/28/05. |
|
407 |
Sen. Beyer |
Asks about the new sections in the amendment. |
|
424 |
Dave Heynderickx |
Acting Legislative Counsel. Discusses the changes resulting from the -1 amendment (Exhibit E). |
|
452 |
Sen. Walker |
Inquires about page 153 relating to the name change in a council. |
|
499 |
Heynderickx |
Replies with information on the name change. |
|
443 |
Sen. Walker |
Wonders about the use of several terms in the bill relating to bawdy houses and other certain instances. |
|
TAPE 65, A |
||
|
030 |
Heynderickx |
Cites historical information on these types of changes. |
|
054 |
Chair Burdick |
Declares her support of the changes. |
|
|
|
VOTE: 6-0-1 EXCUSED: 1 - Ringo |
|
065 |
Chair Burdick |
Hearing no objection, declares the motion CARRIED. |
|
067 |
Sen. Starr |
MOTION: Moves HB 2261A to the floor with a DO PASS AS AMENDED recommendation. |
|
|
|
VOTE: 6-0-1 EXCUSED: 1 - Ringo |
|
071 |
Chair Burdick |
Hearing no objection, declares the motion CARRIED. SEN. WALKER will lead discussion on the floor. |
|
075 |
Chair Burdick |
Closes the work session on HB 2261 and opens a public hearing on SB 492. |
|
SB 492 – PUBLIC HEARING |
||
|
085 |
Joe O’Leary |
Counsel. Describes SB 492 relating to the laws regarding driver duties to certain pedestrians. |
|
094 |
Troy E. Costales |
Manager, Transportation Safety Division, Oregon Department of Transportation. Submits testimony and testifies in support of SB 492 (EXHIBIT F). |
|
118 |
Chair Burdick |
Asks if the two provisions of the vehicle code (dealing with signalized and un-signalized intersections) are combined into one provision by passing SB 492. |
|
120 |
Costales |
Agrees, and explains the new situation. |
|
123 |
Chair Burdick |
Inquires about the different bills relating to this issue facing the legislature. |
|
127 |
Costales |
Gives information on the other bills (i.e., HB 2109 in House Transportation) in the session. |
|
133 |
Sen. Starr |
Asks if SB 492 repeals a section of another bill passed last session. |
|
137 |
Costales |
States that it alters a portion of the bill and explains what it changes. |
|
150 |
Chair Burdick |
Opens a combined public hearing on SB 492 & SB 591. |
|
SB 492 & SB 591 – PUBLIC HEARING |
||
|
162 |
Mark Landauer |
Office of Government Relations, Portland. Testifies in support of SB 492. |
|
167 |
Mark Lear |
Manager, Traffic Investigation Group, Portland. Submits testimony and testifies in support of SB 492 & SB 591 (EXHIBIT G). |
|
219 |
Mark Lear |
Points to a graphic that demonstrates the traffic accidents that occurred due to drivers striking a pedestrian in the right of way. |
|
233 |
Chair Burdick |
Wonders about the value of having signalized and non-signalized statutes in one section in a bill. |
|
239 |
Lear |
Stresses that the bill will help law enforcement. Mentions information on possible accident prevention methods. |
|
252 |
Chair Burdick |
Emphasizes that clear painted crosswalks are helpful to drivers to prevent accidents. |
|
264 |
Scott Bricker |
Policy Director, Willamette Pedestrian Coalition. Submits the written testimony of April Bertelsen, President of Willamette Pedestrian Coalition, and testifies in support of SB 492 (EXHIBIT I). |
|
313 |
Chair Burdick |
Closes the public hearing on SB 492. |
|
297 |
Joe O’Leary |
Counsel. Describes SB 591 relating to parts of a roadway that are considered adjacent to the lane in which a driver’s vehicle is traveling. |
|
325 |
Sen. Prozanski |
Declares his support for SB 591 and details the problems this bill will fix. |
|
352 |
Chair Burdick |
Inquires about bicycle lane requirements. |
|
358 |
Sen. Prozanski |
Clarifies the effects of SB 591. |
|
386 |
Mark Lear |
Manager, Traffic Investigation Group, Portland. Offers clarification on the effects of SB 591. |
|
402 |
Chair Burdick |
Asks about the lane changes in the bill. |
|
404 |
Lear |
Offers information on the lane changes involved with the bill. |
|
428 |
Chair Burdick |
Closes the public hearing on SB 591 and opens a public hearing on SB 938. |
|
SB 938 – PUBLIC HEARING |
||
|
438 |
Joe O’Leary |
Counsel. Describes SB 938 relating to providing exceptions for bicycles for the offense of unsafe passing on the right. |
|
456 |
Scott Bricker |
Policy Director, Bicycle Transportation Alliance. Submits testimony and testifies in support of SB 938 (EXHIBIT J) |
|
476 |
Doug Parrow |
Board of Directors, Bicycle Transportation Alliance. Testifies in support of SB 938. Details the possible amendments they would suggest. |
|
TAPE 64, B |
||
|
038 |
Ray Thomas |
Portland bicycle lawyer. Submits testimony and testifies in support of SB 938 (EXHIBIT K). |
|
081 |
Thomas |
Talks about the federal Universal Vehicle Code (UVC) dealing with passing on the right. Discusses paragraph 2 of SB 938. |
|
110 |
Thomas |
Addresses the issue of motorcycles passing a car in the same lane. |
|
150 |
Thomas |
Brings up the problems in current bicycle laws. |
|
178 |
Parrow |
Introduces a possible amendment for SB 938 (EXHIBIT L). |
|
201 |
Chair Burdick |
Expresses her confusion on the idea of a bike lane being on the right of a right turn lane. |
|
205 |
Parrow |
Cites examples of right turn lanes where the bike lane is on the right. |
|
221 |
Rep. Jackie Dingfelder |
House District 45. Testifies in support of SB 938. Declares that the bill will clarify different problems facing cyclists. |
|
274 |
Kat Iverson |
Washington County. Submits testimony and testifies in opposition to SB 938 (EXHIBIT M). |
|
310 |
Sen. Prozanski |
Asks about the 100 feet turn signal law. |
|
314 |
Iverson |
Agrees that motorists are legally required to use their turn signals, but cites examples of how this could still cause danger. Continues testimony in opposition to SB 938, discussing examples of how the bill will be dangerous to both drivers and cyclists. |
|
364 |
Iverson |
Cites examples of how SB 938 creates dangers for both cyclists and drivers. |
|
415 |
Iverson |
Discusses SB 938 conflicting with other laws. Talks about possible conceptual amendments. |
|
478 |
Chair Burdick |
Closes the public hearing on SB 938and opens a work session on SB 230. |
|
SB 230 – WORK SESSION |
||
|
482 |
Joe O’Leary |
Counsel. Describes SB 230 relating to establishing a procedure for appointing a guardian ad litem. Discusses the -1 amendment (EXHIBIT N). |
|
TAPE 65, B |
||
|
034 |
Wendy Johnson |
Deputy Director, Oregon Law Commission. Discusses the reasoning behind the bill. |
|
050 |
Chair Burdick |
Asks if the purpose of the guardian ad litem is meant to preserve the rights of the parents. |
|
053 |
Johnson |
Replies yes, and offers information. |
|
062 |
Sen. Prozanski |
MOTION: Moves to ADOPT SB 230-1 amendments dated 1/28/05. |
|
|
|
VOTE: 6-0-1 EXCUSED: 1 - Whitsett |
|
065 |
Chair Burdick |
Hearing no objection, declares the motion CARRIED. |
|
066 |
Sen. Prozanski |
MOTION: Moves SB 230A to the floor with a DO PASS AS AMENDED recommendation. |
|
069 |
Sen. Beyer |
Opposes the motion to move SB 320A to the floor. Offers information as to his opposition to the bill. |
|
091 |
|
VOTE: 4-3-0 AYE: 4 - Prozanski, Ringo, Walker, Burdick NAY: 3 - Beyer, Starr C., Whitsett |
|
094 |
Chair Burdick |
The motion CARRIES. SEN. PROZANSKI will lead discussion on the floor. |
|
102 |
Chair Burdick |
Closes the work session on SB 230 and opens a work session on SB 921. |
|
SB 921 – WORK SESSION |
||
|
106 |
Joe O’Leary |
Counsel. Describes SB 921 relating to requiring the petitioner for adoption to serve summons and motion and order to show cause on certain parents who do not consent to adoption. Introduces and discusses the -1 amendment (EXHIBIT O). |
|
121 |
Wendy Johnson |
Deputy Director, Oregon Law Commission. Details the history of the bill and the status of the amendments. |
|
135 |
Sen. Prozanski |
MOTION: Moves to ADOPT SB 921-1 amendments dated 3/9/05. |
|
138 |
Sen. Beyer |
Asks about a possible fiscal impact. |
|
142 |
O’Leary |
States there is a negative fiscal impact statement. |
|
|
|
VOTE: 6-0-1 EXCUSED: 1 - Starr |
|
094 |
Chair Burdick |
Hearing no objection, declares the motion CARRIED. |
|
148 |
Sen. Prozanski |
MOTION: Moves SB 921 to the floor with a DO PASS AS AMENDED recommendation. |
|
|
|
VOTE: 6-0-1 EXCUSED: 1 - Starr |
|
152 |
Chair Burdick |
Hearing no objection, declares the motion CARRIED. SEN. WALKER will lead discussion on the floor. |
|
155 |
Chair Burdick |
Closes the work session on SB 921 and opens a work session on SB 238. |
|
SB 238 – WORK SESSION |
||
|
157 |
William E. Taylor |
Counsel. Describes SB 238 relating to the rights of firefighters, tobacco users and members of the Legislative Assembly. Discusses the -1 amendment (EXHIBIT P). |
|
172 |
Wendy Johnson |
Deputy Director, Oregon Law Commission (OLC). Details her support for SB 238. |
|
192 |
Sen. Ringo |
Asks about the policy reasoning behind the bill. |
|
193 |
Johnson |
Responds why the OLC took on the drafting of this bill. |
|
232 |
Sen. Prozanski |
MOTION: Moves to ADOPT SB 238-1 amendments dated 2/21/05. |
|
237 |
Sen. Beyer |
Expresses his belief that tobacco users should have the same rights as others. |
|
251 |
Chair Burdick |
VOTE: 4-2-1 AYE: 4 - Prozanski, Ringo, Walker, Burdick NAY: 2 - Beyer, Whitsett EXCUSED: 1 - Starr C. |
|
251 |
Chair Burdick |
The motion CARRIES. |
|
254 |
Sen. Prozanski |
MOTION: Moves SB 238A to the floor with a DO PASS AS AMENDED recommendation. |
|
260 |
Johnson |
Discusses the employment discrimination against tobacco users. |
|
|
|
VOTE: 7-0-0 AYE: 7 - Beyer, Prozanski, Ringo, Starr C., Walker, Whitsett, Burdick |
|
284 |
Chair Burdick |
The motion CARRIES. SEN. BURDICK will lead discussion on the floor. |
|
291 |
Chair Burdick |
Closes the work session on SB 238 and opens a work session on SB 239. |
|
SB 239 – WORK SESSION |
||
|
299 |
William E. Taylor |
Counsel. Describes SB 239 relating to modifying the list of protected classes in civil rights law. |
|
306 |
Sen. Prozanski |
MOTION: Moves SB 239 to the floor with a DO PASS recommendation. |
|
311 |
Sen. Beyer |
Explains his hesitance to support a bill that might change legislative intent. |
|
|
|
VOTE: 6-0-1 EXCUSED: 1 - Ringo |
|
325 |
Chair Burdick |
Hearing no objection, declares the motion CARRIED. SEN. WALKER will lead discussion on the floor. |
|
329 |
Chair Burdick |
Closes the work session on SB 239 and adjourns the meeting at 2:58 p.m. |
|
|
|
|
EXHIBIT SUMMARY