HOUSE COMMITTEE ON ENERGY AND THE ENVIRONMENT

TAPE LOG

April 30, 2007 Hearing Room C

1:00 P.M. Tapes 92 - 95

MEMBERS PRESENT: Rep. Jackie Dingfelder, Chair

Rep. Chuck Burley, Vice-Chair

Rep. Ben Cannon, Vice-Chair

Rep. E. Terry Beyer

Rep. Bob Jenson

Rep. Greg Macpherson

Rep. Greg Smith

STAFF PRESENT: Cat McGinnis, Committee Administrator

Beth Patrino, Committee Administrator

Ian Tolleson, Committee Assistant

MEASURES/ISSUES HEARD:

SB 838A – Work Session

HB 3543 – Work Session

HB 3500 – Work Session

HB 2564 – Work Session

HB 3203 – Work Session

HB 2566 – Work Session

This tape log is in compliance with Senate and House Rules. For complete contents, please refer to the cassette tapes.

TAPE # AND SIDE	COUNTER NUMBER	BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF SUBJECT MATTER OR CHANGE IN SPEAKER
92A		Chair Dingfelder calls the meeting to order at 1:13 p.m.
SB 838 – WORK SESSION
	012	Dave Heynderickx, Special Counsel, Legislative Counsel (EXHIBIT A)
	046	Chair Dingfelder
	048	Heynderickx
	058	Rep. Burley
	065	Heynderickx
	075	Rep. Burley
	088	Heynderickx
	096	Rep. Cannon
	097	Heynderickx
92A	099	Rep. Cannon
	101	Heynderickx
	116	Rep. Cannon
	121	Heynderickx
	162	Rep. Cannon
	166	Heynderickx
	178	Rep. Burley
	180	Heynderickx
	212	Chair Dingfelder
	215	Heynderickx
	273	Chair Dingfelder
	276	Heynderickx
	336	Chair Dingfelder
	337	Heynderickx
	379	Chair Dingfelder
	392	Lee Sparling, Utility Program Director, Public Utility Commission
	425	Chair Dingfelder
	432	Sparling
	470	Rep. Burley
93A	018	Sparling
	030	Chair Dingfelder
	032	MOTION: Rep. Burley moves to ADOPT SB 838A-30 amendments dated 4/23/07.
	050	Rep. Cannon
	057	Rep. Macpherson
	061	Chair Dingfelder
	071	VOTE: 3-4-0 AYE: 3 - Burley, Jenson, Smith G. NAY: 4 - Beyer, Cannon, Macpherson, Dingfelder
		Chair Dingfelder declares the motion FAILED.
	073	MOTION: Rep. Burley moves to ADOPT SB 838A-41 amendments dated 4/25/07.
	097	Rep. Macpherson
	108	Chair Dingfelder
	111	VOTE: 3-4-0 AYE: 3 - Burley, Jenson, Smith G. NAY: 4 - Beyer, Cannon, Macpherson, Dingfelder
		Chair Dingfelder declares the motion FAILED.
	114	MOTION: Rep. Burley moves to ADOPT SB 838A-59 amendments dated 4/27/07.
	117	Chair Dingfelder
93A	122	VOTE: 3-4-0 AYE: 3 - Burley, Jenson, Smith G. NAY: 4 - Beyer, Cannon, Macpherson, Dingfelder
		Chair Dingfelder declares the motion FAILED.
	125	MOTION: Rep. Burley moves to ADOPT SB 838A-60 amendments dated 4/27/07.
	142	VOTE: 3-4-0 AYE: 3 - Burley, Jenson, Smith G. NAY: 4 - Beyer, Cannon, Macpherson, Dingfelder
		Chair Dingfelder declares the motion FAILED.
	145	Chair Dingfelder
	147	MOTION: Rep. Burley moves to ADOPT SB 838A-19 amendments dated 4/16/07.
	174	Rep. Macpherson
	190	Rep. Jenson
	200	VOTE: 3-4-0 AYE: 3 - Burley, Jenson, Smith G. NAY: 4 - Beyer, Cannon, Macpherson, Dingfelder
		Chair Dingfelder declares the motion FAILED.
	206	Chair Dingfelder
	208	Rep. Burley
	214	Chair Dingfelder
	215	MOTION: Rep. Cannon moves to ADOPT SB 838A-43 amendments dated 4/25/07.
	217	Chair Dingfelder
	220	Rep. Cannon
	225	VOTE: 7-0-0 AYE: 7 - Beyer, Burley, Cannon, Jenson, Macpherson, Smith G., Dingfelder
		Chair Dingfelder declares the motion CARRIED.
	229	MOTION: Rep. Cannon moves to ADOPT SB 838-44 amendments dated 4/25/07.
	230	Chair Dingfelder
	234	Rep. G. Smith
	236	Rep. Burley
	259	Chair Dingfelder
	164	VOTE: 7-0-0 AYE: 7 - Beyer, Burley, Cannon, Jenson, Macpherson, Smith G., Dingfelder
		Chair Dingfelder declares the motion CARRIED.
	266	MOTION: Rep. Cannon moves to ADOPT SB 838A-46 amendments dated 4/25/07.
	267	Chair Dingfelder
	269	Rep. Cannon
93A	274	Chair Dingfelder
	283	VOTE: 7-0-0 AYE: 7 - Beyer, Burley, Cannon, Jenson, Macpherson, Smith G., Dingfelder
		Chair Dingfelder declares the motion CARRIED.
	286	MOTION: Rep. Cannon moves to ADOPT SB 838A-48 amendments dated 4/25/07.
	287	Chair Dingfelder
	288	Rep. Cannon
	292	Chair Dingfelder
	297	VOTE: 7-0-0 AYE: 7 - Beyer, Burley, Cannon, Jenson, Macpherson, Smith G., Dingfelder
		Chair Dingfelder declares the motion CARRIED.
	299	MOTION: Rep. Cannon moves to ADOPT SB 838A-53 amendments dated 4/26/07.
	302	Chair Dingfelder
	307	Heynderickx
	318	Chair Dingfelder
	322	Heynderickx
	325	VOTE: 6-1-0 AYE: 6 - Beyer, Cannon, Jenson, Macpherson, Smith G., Dingfelder NAY: 1 - Burley
		Chair Dingfelder declares the motion CARRIED.
	329	Chair Dingfelder
	338	MOTION: Rep. Cannon moves to ADOPT SB 838A-63 amendments dated 4/30/07.
	339	Chair Dingfelder
	340	Rep. Cannon
	358	VOTE: 4-3-0 AYE: 4 - Beyer, Cannon, Macpherson, Dingfelder NAY: 3 - Burley, Jenson, Smith G.
		Chair Dingfelder declares the motion CARRIED.
	360	MOTION: Rep. Cannon moves SB 838A to the floor with a DO PASS AS AMENDED recommendation.
	362	VOTE: 4-3-0 AYE: 4 - Beyer, Cannon, Macpherson, Dingfelder NAY: 3 - Burley, Jenson, Smith G.
		Chair Dingfelder declares the motion CARRIED.
The following prepared testimony is submitted for the record without public testimony:
		Pat Larson, Union County Cattlemen (EXHIBIT B)
	365	Chair Dingfelder
HB 3543 – WORK SESSION
	410	David Van’t Hof, Sustainability Policy Advisor, Governor’s Office (EXHIBIT C)
92B	026	Chair Dingfelder
	027	Rep. Burley
	031	Van’t Hof
	039	Rep. G. Smith
	041	Van’t Hof
	050	Rep. G. Smith
	058	Van’t Hof
	065	Rep. Burley
	070	Van’t Hof
	081	Chair Dingfelder
	086	MOTION: Rep. Cannon moves to ADOPT HB 3543-2 amendments dated 4/30/07.
	088	Chair Dingfelder
	089	Rep. G. Smith
	094	Rep. Burley
	106	Chair Dingfelder
	128	VOTE: 5-2-0 AYE: 5 - Beyer, Cannon, Macpherson, Smith G., Dingfelder NAY: 2 - Burley, Jenson
		Chair Dingfelder declares the motion CARRIED.
	134	MOTION: Rep. Cannon moves HB 3543 to the floor with a DO PASS AS AMENDED recommendation and the SUBSEQUENT REFERRAL to the committee on Ways & Means BE RESCINDED.
	136	Chair Dingfelder
	139	Rep. Cannon
	151	Rep. Jenson
	206	Rep. G. Smith
	226	Rep. Cannon
	251	Rep. Jenson
	278	Chair Dingfelder
	298	VOTE: 4-3-0 AYE: 4 - Beyer, Cannon, Macpherson, Dingfelder NAY: 3 - Burley, Jenson, Smith G.
		Chair Dingfelder declares the motion CARRIED.
	305	Rep. Jenson
The following prepared testimony is submitted for the record without public testimony:
		Mike Gaudern, Oregon Small Woodlands Association (EXHIBIT D)
	309	Chair Dingfelder
HB 3500 – WORK SESSION
92B	323	MOTION: Rep. Cannon moves HB 3500 to the floor WITHOUT RECOMMENDATION as to passage and BE REFERRED to the committee on Revenue by prior reference.
	325	Chair Dingfelder
	327	VOTE: 5-1-1 AYE: 5 - Beyer, Cannon, Macpherson, Smith G., Dingfelder NAY: 1 - Jenson EXCUSED: 1 - Burley
		Chair Dingfelder declares the motion CARRIED.
	342	Rep. Jenson
HB 2564 – WORK SESSION
	352	Chair Dingfelder
	364	Tom Quintal, citizen
	445	Chair Dingfelder
93B	009	Beth Patrino, Committee Administrator (EXHIBIT E)
	048	Chair Dingfelder
	049	Rep. Jenson
	099	Chair Dingfelder
	103	Debbie Colbert, Senior Policy Coordinator, Oregon Water Resources Department
	112	Chair Dingfelder
	121	Melissa Leoni, Senior Policy Coordinator, Oregon Watershed Enhancement Board
	127	Rep. Jenson
	139	Chair Dingfelder
	142	Rep. Jenson
	147	Chair Dingfelder
	150	Rep. Cannon
	156	Colbert
	160	Rep. Cannon
	163	Colbert
	171	Chair Dingfelder
	172	MOTION: Rep. Jenson moves to ADOPT HB 2564-4 amendments dated 4/30/07 and that the measure be FURTHER AMENDED on page 2, line 3, by changing "shall" to "may".
		VOTE: 7-0-0
		Chair Dingfelder, hearing no objection, declares the motion CARRIED.
	176	Rep. Macpherson
93B	181	MOTION: Rep. Jenson moves HB 2564 with the concept ional amendment to the floor with a DO PASS AS AMENDED recommendation.
		VOTE: 6-1-0 AYE: 6 - Beyer, Burley, Cannon, Jenson, Macpherson, Dingfelder NAY: 1 - Smith G.
		Chair Dingfelder declares the motion CARRIED.
	184	Chair Dingfelder
	196	MOTION: Rep. Jenson moves HB 2564 to the floor with a DO PASS AS AMENDED recommendation and BE REFERRED to the committee on Ways and Means by prior reference..
	196	VOTE: 4-3-0 AYE: 4 - Beyer, Cannon, Macpherson, Dingfelder NAY: 3 - Burley, Jenson, Smith G.
		Chair Dingfelder declares the motion CARRIED.
The following prepared testimony is submitted for the record without public testimony:
		Cat McGinnis, Committee Administrator (EXHIBIT F)
	217	Chair Dingfelder recesses the meeting at 3:02 pm
94A	001	Chair Dingfelder reconvenes the meeting at 5:19 pm
HB 3203 – WORK SESSION
	005	Cat McGinnis, Committee Administrator
	008	Chair Dingfelder
	011	Willie Tiffany, Senior Associate, League of Oregon Cities (EXHIBIT G)
	103	Kimberley Priestley, Assistant Director, WaterWatch of Oregon
	106	Chair Dingfelder
	108	Tiffany
	119	Rep. Burley
	129	Tiffany
	147	Presley
	157	Rep. Burley
	169	Tiffany
	181	Chair Dingfelder
	184	Tiffany
	196	Rep. Jenson
	207	Chair Dingfelder
	210	Tiffany
	217	Chair Dingfelder
	219	Debbie Colbert, Senior Policy Coordinator, Oregon Water Resources Department
	225	Chair Dingfelder
	229	Rep. Jenson
	242	Chair Dingfelder
	250	Rep. Jenson
	254	Chair Dingfelder
	255	Rep. Burley
HB 2566 – WORK SESSION
94A	262	Chair Dingfelder
	268	MOTION: Rep. Cannon moves to ADOPT HB 2566-2 amendments dated 4/27/07.
	271	Chair Dingfelder
	273	Rep. Macpherson
	292	VOTE: 4-3-0 AYE: 4 - Beyer, Cannon, Macpherson, Dingfelder NAY: 3 - Burley, Jenson, Smith G.
		Chair Dingfelder declares the motion CARRIED.
	307	MOTION: Rep. Burley moves to ADOPT HB 2566-3 amendments dated 4/30/07.
	308	Chair Dingfelder
	310	Rep. Burley
	312	Chair Dingfelder
	314	Richard Kosesan, Representative, Water for Life (EXHIBIT H)
	330	Chair Dingfelder
	338	Kosesan
	360	Chair Dingfelder
	375	Rep. Burley
	386	Chair Dingfelder
	410	Rep. Cannon
	415	Chair Dingfelder
	418	MOTION: Rep. Dingfelder moves to AMEND the motion to ADOPT HB 2566-3 amendments dated 4/30/07 by FURTHER AMENDING the -3 amendments on page 1, line 1&2, by deleting "On page 1 of the printed bill, line 2, delete "amending ORS 537.545;". Delete lines 4 through 31 and delete page 2 and insert:" and by inserting "the -3 amendments between sections 4 & 5 of the -2 amendments with the exception of the emergency clause."
	459	Chair Dingfelder
	464	Rep. Cannon
	477	Chair Dingfelder
95A	011	Rep. Jenson
	019	Chair Dingfelder
	025	VOTE: 4-3-0 AYE: 4 - Beyer, Cannon, Macpherson, Dingfelder NAY: 3 - Burley, Jenson, Smith G.
		Chair Dingfelder declares the motion CARRIED.
	031	Chair Dingfelder
	033	Rep. Jenson
	041	Rep. Macpherson
95A	045	Chair Dingfelder
	046	MOTION: Rep. Macpherson moves to ADOPT HB 2566-3 conceptional amendments dated 4/30/07.
	048	Chair Dingfelder
	049	Rep. Jenson
	053	Rep. Macpherson
	054	Chair Dingfelder
	058	VOTE: 5-2-0 AYE: 5 - Beyer, Cannon, Jenson, Macpherson, Dingfelder NAY: 2 - Burley, Smith G.
		Chair Dingfelder declares the motion CARRIED.
	060	MOTION: Rep. Cannon moves HB 2566 to the floor with a DO PASS AS AMENDED recommendation.
	063	Chair Dingfelder
	066	Rep. Burley
	080	Chair Dingfelder
	081	Rep. Jenson
	097	Rep. Beyer
	106	VOTE: 4-3-0 AYE: 4 - Beyer, Cannon, Macpherson, Dingfelder NAY: 3 - Burley, Jenson, Smith G.
		Chair Dingfelder declares the motion CARRIED.
	114	Chair Dingfelder adjourns meeting at 5:58 pm
	130	MOTION: Rep. Dingfelder moves to SUSPEND the rules for the purpose to re-open the committee meeting and to reopen the work session on HB 3203.
		VOTE: 6-0-1 EXCUSED: 1 - Rep. G. Smith
		Chair Dingfelder, hearing no objection, declares the motion CARRIED.
	131	Chair Dingfelder reconvenes work session on HB 3203
HB 3203 – WORK SESSION
	142	Willie Tiffany, Senior Associate, League of Oregon Cities (EXHIBIT I)
	164	Chair Dingfelder
	165	MOTION: Rep. Macpherson moves to ADOPT HB 3203-1 amendments dated 4/30/07 and that the measure be FURTHER AMENDED on page 2, by inserting "the changes on the hand engrossed version 2 of the -1 amendments".
	169	VOTE: 5-1-1 AYE: 5 - Beyer, Cannon, Jenson, Macpherson, Dingfelder NAY: 1 - Burley EXCUSED: 1 - Smith G.
		Chair Dingfelder declares the motion CARRIED.
95A	174	MOTION: Rep. Macpherson moves HB 3203 to the floor with a DO PASS AS AMENDED recommendation and BE REFERRED to the committee on Ways and Means by prior reference..
	176	Chair Dingfelder
	180	Rep. Jenson
	188	Chair Dingfelder
	198	Tiffany
	201	Rep. Burley
	214	Chair Dingfelder
	216	Tiffany
	228	Rep. Burley
	235	Rep. Macpherson
	239	Tiffany
	246	Chair Dingfelder
	252	VOTE: 4-2-1 AYE: 4 - Beyer, Cannon, Macpherson, Dingfelder NAY: 2 - Burley, Jenson EXCUSED: 1 - Smith G.
		Chair Dingfelder, declares the motion CARRIES.
	259	Chair Dingfelder adjourns meeting at 6:15 pm

EXHIBIT SUMMARY

1. SB 838A, amendment packet, Dave Heynderickx, 23 pp
2. SB 838A, written testimony, Pat Larson, 1 p
3. HB 3543, -2 amendments, David Van’t Hof, 11 pp
4. HB 3543, written testimony, Mike Gaudern, 5 pp
5. HB 2564, -4 amendments, staff, 6 pp
6. HB 2564, written testimony, staff, 16 pp
7. HB 3203, -1 amendments, Willie Tiffany, 3 pp
8. HB 2566, -3 amendments, Richard Kosesan, 3 pp
9. HB 3203, -2 amendments, Willie Tiffany, 2 pp