PUBLIC HEARING AND WORK SESSION

 

TAPES #170 and 171

 

HB 2641, HB 2735

 

HOUSE REVENUE COMMITTEE

MAY 22, 2007, 1:00 P.M.

Hearing Room A State Capitol Building

 

Members Present: Rep. Phil Barnhart Chair

Rep. Tom Butler, Vice Chair

Rep. Tobias Read, Vice Chair

Rep. Vicki Berger

Rep. Scott Bruun

Rep. Sara Gelser

Rep. Diane Rosenbaum

Rep. Brad Witt

 

Member Excused: Rep. Andy Olson

 

Witnesses Present: Rep. Chris Edwards, HD 14, Eugene

Dawn Phillips representing Rep. Jerry Krummel, HD 26, Wilsonville

Sen. Gary George, SD 12, Newberg

John Van Landingham, Lane County Legal Aid & Advocacy Center

Patricia Schwoch, Manufactured Home Owners of Oregon, Inc.

Chuck Carpenter, Manufactured Housing Communities of Oregon

Peter Ferris, Oregon Manufactured Homeowners United

Barbara Mitchell, resident of Eugene

Fred Schwoch, Manufactured Homeowners of Oregon

Rep. Mike Schaufler, HD 48, Happy Valley

Linda Ludwig, League of Oregon Cities

Dennis Mulvihill, Washington County

Kelly Ross, Special Districts Association

Alex Cuyler, City of Eugene

Charlotte Lehan, Mayor of Wilsonville

Don Miner, Oregon Manufactured Housing Association

Ann Taylor

Al Baker, resident of Seminole Estates in Washington County

 

Staff Present: Paul Warner, Legislative Revenue Officer

Steve Meyer, Economist, Legislative Revenue Office

Mary Ayala, Economist, Legislative Revenue Office

Carol Phillips, Committee Assistant

 

TAPE 170, SIDE A

003

Chair Barnhart

Calls meeting to order at 1:11 P.M.

004

Chair Barnhart

Opened Work Session on HB 2641.

006

Steve Meyer

Steve Meyer, Economist, Legislative Revenue Office (Exhibits A, B)

012

Chair Barnhart

 

013

Meyer

 

016

Chair Barnhart

 

019

Vice Chair Butler

 

025

Meyer

 

 

Vice Chair Butler

MOTION: MOVES HB 2641 TO THE FLOOR WITH A DO PASS RECOMMENDATION.

033

Chair Barnhart

 

034

Rep. Berger

 

048

Chair Barnhart

 

049

Rep. Witt

 

055

Vice Chair Butler

 

063

Rep. Gelser

 

085

Chair Barnhart

 

092

Chair Barnhart

ORDER: ROLL CALL VOTE: MEMBERS VOTING AYE: BERGER, BUTLER, GELSER, READ, ROSENBAUM, WITT, BARNHART. MEMBERS EXCUSED: BRUUN, OLSON. MOTION PASSES: 7-0-2.

101

Chair Barnhart

Closed Work Session on HB 2641.

105

Chair Barnhart

Opened Public Hearing on HB 2735.

108

Mary Ayala

Steve Meyer, Economist, Legislative Revenue Office (Exhibits C, D, E)

161

Chair Barnhart

 

169

Rep. Chris Edwards

Rep. Chris Edwards, HD 14, Eugene

244

Dawn Phillips

Representing Rep. Jerry Krummel, HD 26, Wilsonville

408

Rep. Gelser

 

412

Phillips

 

417

Sen. Gary George

Sen. Gary George, SD 12, Newberg

 

TAPE 171, SIDE A

023

Sen. Gary George

Continuation of comments.

046

Chair Barnhart

 

047

Rep. Chris Edwards

 

062

Chair Barnhart

 

077

John VanLandingham

John Van Landingham, Lane Co. Legal Aid & Advocacy Center (Exhibit F)

358

Patricia Schwoch

Patricia Schwoch, Manufactured Home Owners of Oregon (Exhibit G)

408

Chuck Carpenter

Chuck Carpenter, Manufactured Housing Communities of Oregon

 

TAPE 170, SIDE B

023

Chair Barnhart

 

034

Vice Chair Butler

 

040

Van Landingham

 

042

Vice Chair Butler

 

044

Chair Barnhart

 

052

Peter Ferris

Peter Ferris, Oregon Manufactured Homeowners United (Exhibit J)

115

Chair Barnhart

 

118

Barbara Mitchell

Barbara Mitchell, resident of Eugene (Exhibit H)

182

Fred Schwoch

Fred Schwoch, Manufactured Homeowners of Oregon (Exhibit I)

227

Chair Barnhart

 

228

Rep. Berger

 

230

Chair Barnhart

 

231

Rep. Berger

 

237

Mitchell

 

242

Rep. Berger

 

245

Ferris

 

246

Rep. Berger

 

247

Ferris

 

253

Rep. Berger

 

254

Ferris

 

255

Rep. Berger

 

257

Ferris

 

259

Rep. Berger

 

260

Ferris

 

271

Rep. Berger

 

274

Ferris

 

275

Rep. Berger

 

276

Chair Barnhart

 

278

Rep. Gelser

 

282

Schwoch

 

286

Chair Barnhart

 

287

Rep. Gelser

 

293

Schwoch

 

313

Rep. Gelser

 

322

Schwoch

 

335

Vice Chair Butler

 

348

Chair Barnhart

 

355

Ferris

 

374

Chair Barnhart

 

383

Ferris

 

394

Chair Barnhart

 

398

Van Landingham

 

450

Rep. Gelser

 

454

Van Landingham

 

459

Chair Barnhart

 

465

Rep. Berger

 

477

Vice Chair Butler

 

482

Chair Barnhart

 

 

 

TAPE 171, SIDE B

026

Rep. Miike Schaufler

Rep. Mike Schaufler, HD 48, Happy Valley

050

Chair Barnhart

 

060

Linda Ludwig

Linda Ludwig, League of Oregon Cities (Exhibit K)

093

Dennis Mulvihill

Dennis Mulvihill, Washington County

150

Kelly Ross

Kelly Ross, Special Districts Association

184

Vice Chair Butler

 

194

Mulvihill

 

204

Vice Chair Butler

 

206

Chair Barnhart

 

215

Alex Cuyler

Alex Cuyler, City of Eugene (Exhibit L)

252

Charlotte Lehan

Charlotte Lehan, Mayor of Wilsonville (Exhibit M)

314

Don Miner

Don Miner, Oregon Manufactured Housing Association

363

Chair Barnhart

 

374

Ann Taylor

Ann Taylor

435

Chair Barnhart

 

439

Al Baker

Al Baker, resident of Seminole Estates in Washington County

 

TAPE 172, SIDE A

023

Al Baker

Continuation of comments.

065

Chair Barnhart

Closed Public Hearing on HB 2735.

066

Chair Barnhart

Adjourns meeting at 3:05 p.m.

 

 

 

Tape Index Submitted by:

 

 

 

 

Carol Phillips

House Committee Assistant

 

 

 

Exhibit Summary:

  1. HB 2641, Staff measure summary, Steve Meyer.
  2. HB 2641, Revenue impact statement, Steve Meyer.
  3. HB 2735, Staff measure summary, Mary Ayala.
  4. HB 2735, -A3 amendments, LRO staff.
  5. HB 2735, -A5 amendments, LRO staff.
  6. HB 2735, Written testimony, John Van Landingham.
  7. HB 2735, Written testimony, Patricia Schwoch.
  8. HB 2735, Written testimony, Barbara Mitchell.
  9. HB 2735, Written testimony, Fred Schwoch.
  10. HB 2735, Written testimony, Peter Ferris.
  11. HB 2735, Written testimony, Linda Ludwig.
  12. HB 2735, Written testimony, Alex Cuyler.
  13. HB 2735, Written testimony, Charlotte Lehan.