WORK SESSION

 

TAPES #196 and 197

 

Heard:  HB 3057, SB 1036-A, HB 3514-A, HB 2735-A

 

HOUSE REVENUE COMMITTEE

JUNE 8, 2007, 1:00 P.M.

Hearing Room A – State Capitol Building

 

Members Present:                        Rep. Phil Barnhart Chair

                        Rep. Tom Butler, Vice Chair

                        Rep. Tobias Read, Vice Chair

                        Rep. Vicki Berger

                        Rep. Scott Bruun

                        Rep. Sara Gelser

                        Rep. Andy Olson

                        Rep. Diane Rosenbaum

                        Rep. Brad Witt

 

Witnesses Present:                        Jim Carlson, representing Oregon Health Care Association

                        Kevin Earls, Oregon Association of Hospitals & Health Systems

                        Paul Phillips, representing Coalition for Health Oregon

                        Jeff Stone, Oregon Association of Nurseries

                        Rep. Chris Edwards, HD 14, Eugene

                        Rep. Jerry Krummel, HD 26, Wilsonville

                        Linda Ludwig, League of Oregon Cities

                        Nancy Kane, Housing Community Services Department

                        John Van Landingham, Lane County Legal Aid

                        Alex Cuyler, City of Eugene

                        Rep. Dave Hunt, HD 40, Gladstone

 

Staff Present:                        Paul Warner, Legislative Revenue Officer

                        Chris Allanach, Economist, Legislative Revenue Office

                        Mary Ayala, Economist, Legislative Revenue Office

                        Steve Meyer, Economist, Legislative Revenue Office

                        Carol Phillips, Committee Assistant

 

TAPE 196, SIDE A

003

Chair Barnhart

Calls meeting to order at 1:42 P.M.

005

Chair Barnhart

Opened Work Session on HB 3057.

006

Chris Allanach

Chris Allanach, Economist, Legislative Revenue Office (Exhibits A, B, C)

087

Chair Barnhart

 

090

Vice Chair Butler

 

095

Allanach

 

096

Vice Chair Butler

 

098

Allanach

 

101

Vice Chair Butler

 

103

Allanach

 

104

Chair Barnhart

 

106

Vice Chair Butler

MOTION:  MOVES -3 AMENDMENTS TO HB 3057 BE ADOPTED.

109

Chair Barnhart

 

119

Jim Carlson

Jim Carlson, representing Oregon Health Care Association

129

Kevin Earls

Kevin Earls, Oregon Association of Hospitals & Health Systems

136

Paul Phillips

Paul Phillips, representing Coalition for Health Oregon

144

Chair Barnhart

Temporarily closed Work Session on HB 3057 until Vice Chair Butler returns.

151

Rep. Berger

 

152

Chair Barnhart

 

156

Rep. Berger

 

165

Chair Barnhart

Opened Work Session on HB 3514-A

167

Allanach

Exhibits D,E,F.

178

Chair Barnhart

 

180

Allanach

 

189

Chair Barnhart

 

195

Allanach

 

201

Chair Barnhart

 

202

Allanach

 

210

Vice Chair Read

MOTION:  MOVES -4 AMENDMENTS TO HB 3514-A BE ADOPTED.

214

Rep. Bruun

 

218

Chair Barnhart

 

221

Jeff Stone

Jeff Stone, Oregon Association of Nurseries

227

Chair Barnhart

 

228

Stone

 

229

Chair Barnhart

ORDER:  HEARING NO OBJECTION, THE CHAIR SO ORDERS.

232

Vice Chair Read

MOTION:  MOVES HB 3514-A AS AMENDED TO THE FLOOR WITH A DO PASS RECOMMENDATION.

233

Chair Barnhart

ORDER:  ROLL CALL VOTE:  MEMBERS VOTING AYE:  BERGER, BRUUN, GELSER, OLSON, READ, ROSENBAUM, WITT, BARNHART.  MEMBER EXCUSED:  BUTLER.  MOTION PASSES 8-0-1.

245

Chair Barnhart

Closed Work Session on HB 3514-A.

253

Chair Barnhart

Opened Work Session on SB 1036-A.

274

Chair Barnhart

Closed Work Session on SB 1036-A.

280

Chair Barnhart

Opened Work Session on HB 2735-A.

295

Rep. Chris Edwards

Rep. Chris Edwards, HD 14, Eugene

351

Chair Barnhart

 

359

Rep. C. Edwards

 

360

Chair Barnhart

 

361

Rep. C. Edwards

 

375

Rep. Gelser

 

383

Rep. C. Edwards

 

385

Rep. Gelser

 

400

Rep. C. Edwards

 

415

Chair Barnhart

 

419

Rep. Gelser

 

421

Chair Barnhart

 

423

Rep. Jerry Krummel

Rep. Jerry Krummel. HD 26, Wilsonville (Exhibits H, I)

461

Chair Barnhart

 

462

Rep. Krummel

 

 

TAPE 197, SIDE A

023

Rep. Krummel

Continuation of comments.

057

Chair Barnhart

 

058

Rep. Krummel

 

107

Chair Barnhart

 

110

Rep. Krummel

 

111

Chair Barnhart

 

129

Mary Ayala

Mary Ayala, Economist, Legislative Revenue Office (Exhibits G, J, K, L, M, N, O, P, Q)

145

Chair Barnhart

 

148

Ayala

 

154

Chair Barnhart

 

156

Ayala

 

162

Chair Barnhart

 

164

Ayala

 

178

Chair Barnhart

 

180

Ayala

 

183

Chair Barnhart

 

184

Rep. Berger

 

187

Chair Barnhart

 

190

Ayala

 

201

Rep. Berger

 

202

Chair Barnhart

 

203

Rep. Berger

 

205

Chair Barnhart

 

211

Linda Ludwig

Linda Ludwig, League of Oregon Cities

233

Chair Barnhart

 

235

Ludwig

 

236

Chair Barnhart

 

237

Ludwig

 

238

Chair Barnhart

 

240

Ludwig

 

242

Chair Barnhart

 

248

Ludwig

 

250

Chair Barnhart

 

251

Ludwig

 

254

Chair Barnhart

 

255

Ludwig

 

257

Chair Barnhart

 

261

Ayala

 

262

Chair Barnhart

 

267

John VanLandingham

John Van Landingham, Lane County Legal Aid

290

Vice Chair Butler

 

291

Van Landingham

 

292

Chair Barnhart

 

293

Van Landingham

 

296

Chair Barnhart

 

298

Van Landingham

 

302

Chair Barnhart

 

311

Vice Chair Butler

 

314

Rep. Gelser

MOTION:  MOVES -11 AMENDMENTS TO HB 2735-A BE ADOPTED.

316

Chair Barmhart

 

318

Rep. Gelser

 

331

Rep. Bruun

 

359

Vice Chair Butler

 

370

Van Landingham

 

384

Chair Barnhart

 

389

Vice Chair Butler

Objects to -11 amendments.

392

Chair Barnhart

Rep. Olson, Rep. Berger, and Rep. Bruun also object to -11 amendments.

396

Chair Barnhart

ORDER:  OVER THE OBJECTION OF REPS. BERGER, BRUUN, BUTLER, AND OLSON, THE CHAIR SO ORDERS TO -11 AMENDMENTS BE ADOPTED.

398

Chair Barnhart

 

405

Ayala

 

416

Read

MOTION:MOVES THE -13 AMENDMENTS TO HB 2735-A BE ADOPTED.

419

Chair Barnhart

 

420

Vice Chair Butler

 

426

Chair Barnhart

 

430

Chair Barnhart

 

440

Vice Chair Butler

 

446

Chair Barnhart

ORDER:  HEARING NO OBJECTION, THE CHAIR SO ORDERS.

452

Chair Barnhart

Closed Work Session on HB 2735-A.

460

Chair Barnhart

Re-Opened Work Session on HB 3057.

 

Chair Barnhart

ORDER:  HEARING NO OBJECTION, THE CHAIR ORDERS THE ADOPTION OF THE -3 AMENDMENTS TO HB 3057.

480

Vice Chair Read

MOTION:  MOVES HB 3057 AS AMENDED TO THE FLOOR WITH A DO PASS RECOMMENDATION.

482

Chair Barnhart

 

485

Rep. Berger

 

 

TAPE 196, SIDE B

035

Rep. Bruun

 

044

Rep. Gelser

 

050

Rep. Olson

 

055

Vice Chair Butler

 

073

Chair Barnhart

 

091

Chair Barnhart

ORDER:  ROLL CALL VOTE:  MEMBERS VOTING AYE:  BERGER, BRUUN, GELSER, OLSON, READ, ROSENBAUM, WITT, BARNHART.  MEMBER VOTING NO:  BUTLER.  MOTION PASSES 8-1-0.

099

Chair Barnhart

Closed Work Session on HB 3057.

101

Chair Barnhart

Re-Opened Work Session on HB 2735-A.

109

Chair Barnhart

 

113

Ayala

 

116

Chair Barnhart

 

117

Ayala

 

120

Chair Barnhart

 

128

Read

MOTION:  MOVES -14 AMENDMENTS TO HB 2735-A BE ADOPTED.

129

Chair Barnhart

ORDER:  HEARING NO OBJECTION, THE CHAIR SO ORDERS.

133

Ayala

 

146

Chair Barnhart

 

148

Ayala

 

149

Van Landingham

 

153

Chair Barnhart

 

158

Chair Barnhart

Recess…call of house 2:48 p.m.  Re-convened at 3:08 p.m.

161

Chair Barnhart

 

165

Vice Chair Butler

MOTION:  MOVES -15 AMENDMENTS TO HB 2735-A BE ADOPTED.

168

Chair Barnhart

ORDER:  HEARING NO OBJECTION, THE CHAIR SO ORDERS.

171

Chair Barnhart

 

173

Ayala

Exhibit R.

195

Chair Barnhart

 

196

Ayala

 

214

Chair Barnhart

 

218

Vice Chair Butler

 

219

Chair Barnhart

 

220

Van Landingham

 

221

Chair Barnhart

 

225

Nancy Kane

Nancy Kane, Housing Community Services Department

228

Chair Barnhart

 

232

Vice Chair Butler

 

233

Van Landingham

 

237

Vice Chair Butler

 

240

Van Landingham

 

252

Vice Chair Butler

MOTION:MOVES THE -19 AMENDMENTS TO HB 2735-A BE ADOPTED.

256

Chair Barnhart

ORDER:  HEARING NO OBJECTION, THE CHAIR SO ORDERS.

266

Ayala

 

273

Chair Barnhart

 

274

Ayala

 

277

Chair Barnhart

 

278

Ayala

 

279

Chair Barnhart

 

281

Vice Chair Butler

 

282

Ayala

 

285

Chair Barnhart

 

293

Vice Chair Butler

 

297

Van Landingham

 

314

Rep. Gelser

 

321

Chair Barnhart

 

322

Rep. Gelser

 

324

Chair Barnhart

 

326

Rep. Olson

 

331

Chair Barnhart

 

332

Van Landingham

 

362

Alex Cuyler

Alex Cuyler, City of Eugene

385

Rep. Olson

MOTION:  MOVES -8 AMENDMENTS TO HB 2735-A BE ADOPTED.

391

Chair Barnhart

 

392

Rep. Olson

 

393

Vice Chair Butler

 

407

Chair Barnhart

 

425

Vice Chair Butler

 

428

Chair Barnhart

 

431

Cuyler

 

439

Chair Barnhart

ORDER:  HEARING NO OBJECTION, THE CHAIR SO ORDERS.

448

Vice Chair Read

MOTION:  MOVES HB 2735-A AS AMENDED TO THE FLOOR WITH A DO PASS RECOMMENDATION.

452

Chair Barnhart

 

462

Vice Chair Butler

 

478

Chair Barnhart

 

480

Rep. Bruun

 

485

Chair Barnhart

ORDER:  ROLL CALL VOTE:  MEMBERS VOTING AYE:  GELSER, OLSON, READ, ROSENBAUM, WITT, BARNHART.  MEMBERS VOTING NO:  BRUUN, BUTLER.  MEMBER EXCUSED:  BERGER.  MOTION PASSES:  6-2-1

 

TAPE 197, SIDE B

034

Vice Chair Butler

Served notice of possible Minority Report.

036

Chair Barnhart

Closed Work Session on HB 2735-A.

047

Chair Barnhart

Opened Work Session on SB 1036-A.

063

Steve Meyer

Exhibits S, T, U, V, W, X, Y.

088

Chair Barnhart

 

089

Meyer

 

103

Chair Barnhart

 

105

Meyer

 

124

Chair Barnhart

 

128

Meyer

 

144

Chair Barnhart

 

145

Meyer

 

182

Chair Barnhart

 

186

Meyer

 

196

Chair Barnhart

 

197

Meyer

 

201

Chair Barnhart

 

207

Rep. Dave Hunt

Rep. Dave Hunt, HD 40, Gladstone.

269

Chair Barnhart

Closed Work Session on HB 1036.

283

Chair Barnhart

Adjourned meeting at 3:42 p.m.

 

 

 

Tape Index Submitted by:

 

 

 

 

Carol Phillips

House Committee Assistant

 

Exhibit Summary:

  1. HB 3057, Staff measure summary, Chris Allanach.
  2. HB 3057, Revenue impact statement, Chris Allanach.
  3. HB 3057, -3 amendments, LRO staff.
  4. HB 3514, Unlawful employment of aliens, LRO staff.
  5. HB 3514, Written testimony, Jeff Stone.
  6. HB 3514, Written testimony, LRO staff.
  7. HB 2735-A, Staff measure summary, Mary Ayala.
  8. HB 2735, Written testimony, Rep. Jerry Krummel.
  9. HB 2735, Written testimony, Rep. Jerry Krummel.
  10. HB 2735, -A8 amendments, LRO staff.
  11. HB 2735, -A10 amendments, LRO staff.
  12. HB 2735, -A12 amendments, LRO staff.
  13. HB 2735, -A13 amendments, LRO staff.
  14. HB 2735, -A14 amendments, LRO staff.
  15. HB 2735, -A15 amendments, LRO staff.
  16. HB 2735, -A16 amendments, LRO staff.
  17. HB 2735, -A18 amendments, LRO staff.
  18. HB 2735, -A19 amendments, LRO staff.
  19. HB 1036, -A14 amendments, LRO staff.
  20. SB 1036, -A20 amendments, LRO staff.
  21. SB 1036, -A21 amendments, LRO staff.
  22. SB 1036, -A22 amendments, LRO staff.
  23. SB 1036, -A25 amendments, LRO staff.
  24. SB 1036, -A26 amendments, LRO staff.
  25. SB 1036, -A27 amendments, LRO staff.
  26. SB 1036, Written testimony, Rep. Brad Witt.
  27. SB 1036, Written testimony, Alice Norris.