Joint Committee on Ways and Means – 2007 Session

Natural Resources Subcommittee

 

Meeting Index

 

May 1, 2007

Hearing Room H-174

8:30 a.m.

Tapes: 106A, 107A

 

Members Present:

Sen. Devlin, Chair

Sen. Avakian

Sen. Nelson

Rep. Dingfelder, Vice-Chair

Rep. Clem

Rep. Nolan

Rep. Burley

Rep. Garrard

 

Members Excused:

 

 

 

Staff Present:

Paul Siebert, Budget Analyst, Legislative Fiscal Office

Susie Jordan, Budget Analyst, Legislative Fiscal Office

Patti O’Rielly, Committee Assistant, Legislative Fiscal Office

 

Measures or Issues Heard:

HB 5022, Department of Environmental Quality – Public Hearing

HB 5023, Department of Environmental Quality Fee Bill – Public Hearing

HB 3540, Relating to Compensation for Loss of Value of Private Real Property Resulting from Land Use Regulation – Work Session

HB 3546, Relating to Extension of Time for Review of Demands for Compensation by Reason of Land Use Regulations – Work Session

 

This meeting index is in compliance with Senate and House Rules.  For complete content, please refer to the CDs.

Tape #/Counter

Speaker

Issues, Votes, Exhibits

TAPE 106A

 

 

003

Chair Devlin

Calls the hearing to order at 8:37 AM

Opens a Public Hearing on HB 5022, Department of Environmental Quality and HB 5023, Department of Environmental Quality Fee Bill

009

Stephanie  Hallock, Director, Department of Environmental Quality (DEQ)

Enters information in response to requests for information and questions from 4/24/07 public hearing (Exhibit #1)

Continues DEQ budget presentation of Exhibit #4 from 4/23/07

 

078

Chair Devlin

 

079

Ms. Hallock

 

088

Chair Devlin

 

091

Ms. Hallock

 

092

Chair Devlin

 

093

Ms. Hallock

 

107

Chair Devlin

 

111

Ms. Hallock

 

118

Chair Devlin

 

124

Ms. Hallock

 

138

Paul Siebert, Analyst, Legislative Fiscal Office

 

142

Ms. Hallock

 

143

Chair Devlin

 

152

Ms. Hallock

 

155

Chair Devlin

Closes Public Hearing on HB 5022 and HB 5023

Recesses to 9:00 AM

 

Chair Devlin

Reconvenes at 9:37 AM

Opens Work Session on HB 3540, Relating to Compensation for Loss of Value of Private Real Property from Land Use Regulation

171

Susie Jordan, Analyst, Legislative Fiscal Office

Enters HB 3540, Relating to Compensation for Loss of Value of Private Real Property from Land Use Regulation (Exhibit #2)

Enters Legislative Fiscal Office Analysis and Proposed Amendments on HB 3540 (Exhibit #3)

180

Chair Devlin

 

182

Lane Shetterly, Director, Department of Land Conservation and Development

 

203

Chair Devlin

 

206

Richard Whitman, Oregon Department of Justice

 

245

Chair Devlin

 

247

Rep. Garrard

Moves to table HB 3540

248

Chair Devlin

 

252

Ms. Jordan

 

258

Chair Devlin

VOTE:  3 – 5 – 0

Aye:  Sen. Nelson, and Reps. Burley and Garrard

No:  Sens. Avakian and Devlin; and Reps. Nolan, Clem, and Dingfelder

Declares the motion FAILED

Recesses at 9:45 AM

265

Chair Devlin

Reconvenes at 10:03 AM

Reopens Work Session on HB 3540

270

Mr. Whitman

 

278

Chair Devlin

 

279

Vice-Chair Dingfelder

Moves to adopt HB 3540 -11 amendments

279

Chair Devlin

 

280

Rep. Clem

 

285

Mr. Whitman

 

291

Chair Devlin

VOTE:  5 – 2 – 1

Aye:  Sens. Avakian and Devlin; and Reps. Nolan, Clem, and Dingfelder

No:  Sen. Nelson and Rep. Garrard

Exc.:  Rep. Burley

Declares the motion CARRIED

299

Mr. Whitman

 

311

Chair Devlin

 

312

Vice-Chair Dingfelder

Moves to adopt HB 3540 -12 amendments

313

Chair Devlin

At ease

VOTE:  5 – 3 – 0

Aye:  Sens. Avakian and Devlin; and Reps. Nolan, Clem, and Dingfelder

No:  Sen. Nelson and Reps. Burley and Garrard

Declares the motion CARRIED

327

Mr. Whitman

 

332

Chair Devlin

 

332

Vice-Chair Dingfelder

Moves to adopt HB 3540 -17 amendments

333

Chair Devlin

VOTE:  5 – 3 – 0

Aye:  Sens. Avakian and Devlin; and Reps. Nolan, Clem, and Dingfelder

No:  Sen. Nelson and Reps. Burley and Garrard

Declares the motion CARRIED

343

Mr. Whitman

 

349

Chair Devlin

 

350

Vice-Chair Dingfelder

Moves to adopt HB 3540 -22 amendments

352

Rep. Garrard

 

359

Chair Devlin

VOTE:  5 – 3 – 0

Aye:  Sens. Avakian and Devlin; and Reps. Nolan, Clem, and Dingfelder

No:  Sen. Nelson and Reps. Burley and Garrard

Declares the motion CARRIED

364

Mr. Whitman

 

374

Chair Devlin

 

375

Vice-Chair Dingfelder

Moves to adopt HB 3540 -23 amendments

376

Chair Devlin

 

377

Rep. Garrard

 

381

Chair Devlin

VOTE:  5 – 3 – 0

Aye:  Sens. Avakian and Devlin; and Reps. Nolan, Clem, and Dingfelder

No:  Sen. Nelson, and Reps. Burley and Garrard

Declares the motion CARRIED

386

Vice-Chair Dingfelder

Moves HB 3540, as Amended, to the Full Committee with a Do Pass recommendation

393

Chair Devlin

 

400

Rep. Garrard

 

TAPE 107 A

 

 

001

Rep. Garrard

 

010

Chair Devlin

 

011

Rep. Nolan

 

013

Chair Devlin

 

014

Don Schellenberg, Oregon Farm Bureau

 

016

Rep. Nolan

 

019

Mr. Schellenberg

 

033

Chair Devlin

 

034

Sen. Avakian

 

054

Vice-Chair Dingfelder

 

064

Rep. Clem

 

065

Chair Devlin

 

066

Rep. Clem

Potential Conflict of Interest

070

Sen. Nelson

Potential Conflict of Interest

074

Chair Devlin

 

075

Mr. Shetterly

 

079

Chair Devlin

VOTE:  5 – 3 – 0

Aye:  Sens. Avakian and Devlin; and Reps. Nolan, Clem, and Dingfelder

No:  Sen. Nelson, and Reps. Burley and Garrard

Declares the motion CARRIED

086

Chair Devlin

Closes Work Session on HB 3540

Opens Work Session on HB 3546, Relating to an Extension of Time for Review of Demands for Compensation by Reason of Land Use Regulations

089

Ms. Jordan

Enters HB 3546, Relating to an Extension of Time for Review of Demands for Compensation by Reason of Land Use Regulations (Exhibit #4)

Enters Legislative Fiscal Office Analysis and Proposed Amendments on HB 3546 (Exhibit #5)

112

Chair Devlin

 

115

Mr. Shetterly

 

128

Chair Devlin

 

129

Vice-Chair Dingfelder

Moves to adopt HB 3546 -7 amendments

130

Chair Devlin

VOTE:  6 – 1 – 1

Aye:  Sens. Avakian, Devlin and Nelson; and Reps. Nolan, Clem, and Dingfelder

No:  Rep. Garrard

Exc.:  Burley

Declares the motion CARRIED

133

Vice-Chair Dingfelder

Moves HB 3546, as Amended, to the Full Committee with a Do Pass recommendation

135

Chair Devlin

VOTE:  6 – 1 – 1

Aye:  Sens. Avakian, Devlin, and Nelson; and Reps. Nolan, Clem, and Dingfelder

No:  Rep. Garrard

Exc.:  Burley

Declares the motion CARRIED

Adjourns the hearing at 10:23 AM