Joint Committee on Ways and Means 2007 Session

Natural Resources Subcommittee

 

Meeting Index

 

June 21, 2007

Hearing Room H-174

8:30 a.m.

Tapes: 147B

 

Members Present:

Sen. Devlin, Chair

Sen. Avakian

Sen. Nelson

Rep. Dingfelder, Vice-Chair

Rep. Clem

Rep. Nolan

Rep. Burley

Rep. Garrard

Rep. Nathanson, Vice-Chair

 

Members Excused:

 

 

 

Staff Present:

Susie Jordan, Budget Analyst, Legislative Fiscal Office

Paul Siebert, Budget Analyst, Legislative Fiscal Office

Eric Sorenson, Committee Assistant, Legislative Fiscal Office

 

Measures or Issues Heard:

HB 3543-A, Relating to Climate Change Work Session

SB 632, Relating to State Capitol Work Session

 

This meeting index is in compliance with Senate and House Rules. For complete content, please refer to the CDs.

Tape #/Counter

Speaker

Issues, Votes, Exhibits

TAPE 147B

 

 

003

Chair Devlin

Calls the hearing to order at 8:39 AM

005

Chair Devlin

Opens Work Session on SB 632 Relating to State Capitol

007

Susie Jordan, Budget Analyst, Legislative Fiscal Office

Presents SB 632, Relating to State Capitol (Exhibit #1)

Presents SB 632-A3 (Exhibit #2)

019

Sen. Metsger

 

047

Rep. Burley

 

049

Sen. Metsger

 

061

Sen. Avakian

 

073

Rep. Burley

 

084

Rep. Dingfelder

 

100

Chair Devlin

Recesses the committee

101

Chair Devlin

Reconvenes the committee

103

Rep. Nathanson

Moves to adopt SB 632 -3 amendments

104

Chair Devlin

 

 

 

Vote: 6 2 1

Aye: Sens. Avakian, Nelson, and Devlin; Reps. Clem, Nolan, and Nathanson

No: Rep. Burley and Garrard

Exc: Rep. Dingfelder

108

Chair Devlin

Declares the motion CARRIED

112

Chair Devlin

 

113

Rep. Nathanson

Moves SB 632, as Amended, to the Full Committee with a Do Pass recommendation

115

Chair Devlin

 

116

Rep. Garrard

 

125

Chair Devlin

 

 

 

Vote: 6 2 1

Aye: Sens. Avakian, Nelson, and Devlin; Reps. Clem, Nolan, and Nathanson.

No: Reps. Burley and Garrard

Exc: Rep. Dingfelder

126

Chair Devlin

Declares the motion CARRIED

130

Chair Devlin

Closes Work Session on SB 632

143

Chair Devlin

Opens Work Session on HB 3543A Relating to Climate Change

144

Paul Seibert, Budget Analyst, Legislative Fiscal Office

Presents House Bill 3543 (Exhibit #3)

Presents HB 3543-A8 (Exhibit #4)

Presents Legislative Fiscal Office analysis (Exhibit #5)

158

Sen. Nelson

 

163

Rep. Clem

Presents HB 3543-A7 (Exhibit #6)

173

Rep. Dingfelder

 

191

Sen. Nelson

 

194

Rep. Dingfelder

 

206

Rep. Garrard

Presents HB 3543-A3 (Exhibit #7)

209

Chair Devlin

 

216

Rep. Clem

 

228

Rep. Dingfelder

 

242

Rep. Burley

 

260

Chair Devlin

 

281

Rep. Burley

 

282

Chair Devlin

 

283

Rep. Burley

Moves to adopt HB 3543 -3 amendments

286

Mr. Seibert

 

300

Rep. Dingfelder

 

311

Chair Devlin

 

318

Rep. Dingfelder

 

321

Mr. Seibert

 

323

Rep. Dingfelder

 

326

Rep. Clem

 

333

Chair Devlin

 

 

 

Vote: 4 4 1

Aye: Sen. Nelson; Reps. Garrard, Burley, Clem

No: Sens. Avakian and Devlin; Rep. Nathanson and Dingfelder

Exc: Rep. Nolan

339

Chair Devlin

Declares the motion FAILED

340

Rep. Clem

Moves to adopt HB 3543 -7 amendments

341

Chair Devlin

 

 

 

Vote: 5 3 1

Aye: Sen. Nelson; Reps. Garrard, Burley, Clem and Dingfelder

No: Sens. Avakian and Devlin; Rep. Nathanson

Exc: Rep. Nolan

347

Chair Devlin

Declares the motion CARRIED

348

Chair Devlin

 

349

Rep. Dingfelder

Moves to adopt HB 3543 -8 amendments

350

Chair Devlin

 

353

Mr. Seibert

 

359

Chair Devlin

 

 

 

Vote: 5 3 1

Aye: Sens. Avakian and Devlin; Reps. Clem, Nathanson and Dingfelder

No: Sen. Nelson; Reps. Garrard and Burley

Exc: Rep. Nolan

365

 

Declares the motion CARRIED

368

Chair Devlin

 

371

Rep. Dingfelder

Moves HB 3543, as Amended, to the Full Committee with a Do Pass recommendation

 

 

Vote: 5 3 1

Aye: Sens. Avakian and Devlin; Reps. Clem, Nathanson and Dingfelder

No: Sen. Nelson; Rep. Garrard and Burley

Exc: Rep. Nolan

378

Chair

Declares the motion CARRIED

388

Chair Devlin

Close Work Session on HB 3543-A

390

Chair Devlin

Adjourns the meeting at 9:13 AM