WORK SESSION: SB 416, SB 38, SB 39

 

TAPES # 60A-B, 61A-B

 

SENATE FINANCE & REVENUE COMMITTEE

TAPE INDEX

MARCH 15, 2007 8:45 A.M. STATE CAPITOL BUILDING

 

Members Present: Sen. Ryan Deckert, Chair

Sen. Gary George, Vice Chair

Sen. Ginny Burdick

Sen. Rod Monroe

Sen. Bruce Starr

Witnesses Present: Sen. Vicki Walker, District 7

Dan Bates, City of Portland Director of Government Relations

Bob Clay, City of Portland Supervising Planner

Kristina McNitt, Cultural Advocacy Coalition

Roger Roper, Heritage Programs, Parks and Recreation

Tim Martinez, Oregon Bankers Association

Bill Manne, Miller Nash

Debra Buchanan, Oregon Department of Revenue

Jody Wiser, Tax Fairness Oregon

Russ Dondero, Washington County Interfaith Committee on Homelessness

Tom Quintal, Small Scale miner, Salem

Tom Kitchar, Waldo Mining District

James Morales, Oregon Association of County Clerks

Janet Coleman, Oregon Association of County Clerks

Victor Merced, Oregon Housing & Community Development

 

Staff Present: Paul Warner, Legislative Revenue Officer

Mary Ayala, Economist

Chris Allanach, Economist

Barbara Guardino, Committee Assistant

 

 

TAPE 60, SIDE A

004

Chair Deckert

Calls meeting to order at 8:59 a.m. Opens work session for SB 416.

 

WORK SESSION, SB 416

 

013

Sen. Walker

Sen. Vicki Walker, District 7

034

Sen. Walker

(Exhibit B)

057

Chair Deckert

 

059

Sen. Burdick

 

062

Sen. Walker

(Exhibit C)

096

Chair Deckert

 

097

Sen. Monroe

 

103

Chair Deckert

 

105

Sen. Walker

 

115

Chair Deckert

 

116

Sen. Walker

 

142

Sen. Walker

(Exhibit D)

165

Sen. Burdick

 

167

Sen. Walker

 

178

Sen. Burdick

 

179

Sen. Walker

 

181

Chair Deckert

 

192

Bates

Dan Bates, City of Portland Director of Government Relations (Exhibit A)

217

Chair Deckert

 

223

Sen. Monroe

 

226

Bates

 

230

Chair Deckert

 

231

Bates

 

235

Sen. Monroe

 

245

Chair Deckert

 

249

Sen. Monroe

 

256

Sen. Burdick

 

262

Bates

 

265

Sen. Burdick

 

270

Bates

 

271

Sen. Burdick

 

278

Bates

 

285

Sen. Burdick

 

289

Bates

 

295

Chair Deckert

 

300

Bates

 

308

Sen. Monroe

 

311

Chair Deckert

 

312

Bates

 

313

Chair Deckert

 

315

Sen. Burdick

 

319

Sen. Monroe

 

321

Sen. Burdick

 

323

Bates

 

325

Chair Deckert

 

326

Sen. Burdick

 

334

Chair Deckert

 

340

Sen. Burdick

 

344

Chair Deckert

 

346

Sen. Monroe

 

352

Sen. Starr

 

360

Vice Chair George

 

361

Chair Deckert

 

370

McNitt

Kristina McNitt, Cultural Advocacy Coalition (Exhibit E)

388

Chair Deckert

 

394

McNitt

 

423

Chair Deckert

 

439

Sen. Starr

 

445

McNitt

 

 

 

 

TAPE 61, SIDE A

013

Chair Deckert

 

015

Roper

Roger Roper, Heritage Programs, Parks and Recreation

040

Sen. Monroe

 

050

Roper

 

054

McNitt

 

060

Chair Deckert

 

064

Roper

 

065

Chair Deckert

 

066

McNitt

 

073

Chair Deckert

 

075

Sen. Monroe

MOTION: MOVED ADOPTION OF THE SB 416-2 AMENDMENTS

078

Chair Deckert

ORDER: STARR OBJECTED TO THE MOTION; CHAIR DECLARED THE MOTION CARRIED

VOTE: 4-1-0

VOTING AYE: BURDICK, GEORGE, MONROE, DECKERT

VOTING NO: STARR

080

Sen. Monroe

MOTION: MOVED ADOPTION OF THE SB 416-3 AMENDMENTS

082

Chair Deckert

ORDER: STARR OBJECTED TO THE MOTION; CHAIR DECLARED THE MOTION CARRIED

VOTE: 4-1-0

VOTING AYE: BURDICK, GEORGE, MONROE, DECKERT

VOTING NO: STARR

 

084

Sen. Monroe

MOTION: MOVED ADOPTION OF THE SB 416-4 AMENDMENTS

088

Vice Chair George

Is prepared to move SB 416-5 amendments

089

Sen. Burdick

 

092

Vice Chair George

 

101

Chair Deckert

 

107

Sen. Burdick

 

108

Sen. Monroe

Withdraws motion on SB 416-4 amendments

109

Vice Chair George

MOTION: MOVED ADOPTION OF SB 416-5 AMENDMENTS

111

Sen. Starr

 

122

Chair Deckert

ORDER: THERE BEING NO OBJECTION, DECLARED THE MOTION CARRIED

VOTE: 5-0-0

VOTING AYE: BURDICK, GEORGE, MONROE, STARR, DECKERT

135

Sen. Monroe

 

136

Chair Deckert

Closes work session on SB 416; opens work session on SB 39.

 

WORK SESSION, SB 39

 

141

Sen. Monroe

 

146

Allanach

Chris Allanach, Economist (Exhibits M and N)

189

Sen. Monroe

(Exhibit O)

212

Chair Deckert

 

213

Sen. Monroe

 

221

Chair Deckert

 

225

Martinez

Tim Martinez, Oregon Bankers Association

254

Manne

Bill Manne, Miller Nash

274

Chair Deckert

 

275

Manne

 

277

Sen. Burdick

 

280

Chair Deckert

 

286

Manne

 

290

Martinez

 

308

Manne

 

321

Sen. Monroe

 

323

Chair Deckert

 

325

Buchanan

Debra Buchanan, Oregon Department of Revenue

333

Manne

 

349

Buchanan

 

360

Chair Deckert

 

362

Martinez

 

377

Manne

 

416

Buchanan

 

425

Sen. Burdick

 

430

Buchanan

 

435

Manne

 

440

Sen. Starr

 

449

Manne

 

 

 

 

TAPE 60, SIDE B

049

Chair Deckert

 

052

Sen. Monroe

 

055

Buchanan

 

067

Chair Deckert

 

068

Manne

 

078

Sen. Monroe

 

080

Buchanan

 

085

Sen. Monroe

 

092

Chair Deckert

 

097

Martinez

 

115

Manne

 

154

Sen. Monroe

 

156

Manne

 

159

Sen. Monroe

 

161

Chair Deckert

 

162

Sen. Monroe

 

168

Chair Deckert

 

170

Sen. Monroe

 

174

Chair Deckert

 

177

Wiser

Jody Wiser, Tax Fairness Oregon

259

Chair Deckert

 

262

Vice Chair George

 

271

Wiser

 

299

Chair Deckert

Closes work session on SB 39. Opens work session SB 38.

 

 

 

WORK SESSION, SB 38

 

320

Dondero

Russ Dondero, Washington County Interfaith Committee on Homelessness. Refers to testimony submitted February 26 (Exhibit R).

347

Chair Deckert

 

350

Quintal

Tom Quintal, Salem, small-scale miner (Exhibit R)

420

Chair Deckert

 

422

Quintal

(Exhibit V)

425

Chair Deckert

 

428

Quintal

 

440

Chair Deckert

 

 

 

 

TAPE 61, SIDE B

012

Kitchar

Tom Kitchar, Waldo Mining District (Exhibits Y CC)

059

Chair Deckert

 

068

Kitchar

 

069

Chair Deckert

 

071

Vice Chair George

 

072

Chair Deckert

 

078

Morales

James Morales, Oregon Association of County Clerks (Exhibit DD)

094

Coleman

Jan Coleman, Yamhill County Clerk, Oregon Association of County Clerks (Exhibit EE)

109

Chair Deckert

 

120

Merced

Victor Merced, Oregon Housing and Community Development

141

Chair Deckert

Closes work session on SB 38. Adjourns meeting at 10:30 a.m.

 

 

Tape Index Submitted by:

 

 

 

 

 

Barbara J. Guardino, Committee Assistant

 

 

Exhibit Summary:

  1. SB 416, Proposed Amendments SB 416-1, 3/14/07, City of Portland
  2. SB 416, Proposed Amendments SB 416-2, 3/14/07, Walker
  3. SB 416, Proposed Amendments SB 416-3, 3/14/07, Walker
  4. SB 416, Proposed Amendments SB 416-4, 3/14/07, Walker
  5. SB 416, Proposed Amendments SB 416-5, 3/14/07, McNitt
  6. SB 416, summary of amendments 1 4, Ayala
  7. SB 416, Staff Measure Summary, 3/14/07, Ayala
  8. SB 416, Revenue Impact of Proposed Legislation, 3/15/07, Ayala
  9. SB 416, Fiscal Analysis of Proposed Legislation, 3/14/07, Farr
  10. SB 416, City of Portland Bureau of Planning, 3/15/07, Bates
  11. SB 416, Historical Special Assessment: Authorizing Second-Term Residential Applications, July 2006, Bates
  12. SB 416, Portland Development Commission, Limits to Historic Property Special Assessment, 3/15/07, Twete
  13. SB 39, Staff Measure Summary, 3/15/07, Allanach
  14. SB 39, Revenue Impact of Proposed Legislation, 3/14/07, Allanach
  15. SB 39, Proposed Amendment SB 39-2, 3/14/07, Monroe
  16. SB 38, Staff Measure Summary, 3/14/07, Ayala
  17. SB 38, Revenue Impact of Proposed Legislation, 3/14/07, Ayala
  18. SB 38, Arguments Against SB-38, 3/14/07, Quintal
  19. SB 38, Proposed Amendments SB 38-1, 3/1/07, Legislative Counsel
  20. SB 38, Proposed Amendments SB 38-2, 3/1/07, Legislative Counsel
  21. SB 38, Proposed Amendments SB 38-3, 3/14/07, Carter
  22. SB 38, Proposed Amendments SB 38-4, 3/14/07, Quintal
  23. SB 38, Proposed Amendments SB 38-5, 3/14/07, Legislative Counsel
  24. SB 38, Proposed Amendments SB 38-6, 3/14/07, Legislative Counsel
  25. SB 38, Arguments in Opposition of SB-38, Waldo Mining District, 3/15/07, Kitchar
  26. SB 38, Waldo Mining District Re: Senate Bill 38, 3/15/07, Kitchar
  27. SB 38, Arguments for Amending SB-38, Waldo Mining District, 3/15/07, Kitchar
  28. SB 38, Eastern Oregon Mining Association, 3/15/07, Kitchar
  29. SB 38, Westlaw, 2007 Thomson/West No Claim to Orig. U.S. Govt. Works, Kitchar
  30. SB 38, Oregon Association of County Clerks, Regarding: Senate Bill 38, Unrelated Fee/Tax and Unfunded Mandate, 3/14/07, Morales
  31. SB 38, testimony of Jan Coleman, Yamhill County Clerk
  32. SB 38, League of Oregon Cities, 3/15/07, Ludwig