PUBLIC HEARING & WORK SESSION: SB 571-A

 

TAPES # 110A-B, 111A-B, 112A, 113A

 

SENATE FINANCE & REVENUE COMMITTEE

TAPE INDEX

MAY 7, 2007 8:45 AM STATE CAPITOL BUILDING

 

Members Present: Sen. Ryan Deckert, Chair

Sen. Gary George, Vice Chair

Sen. Ginny Burdick

Sen. Rod Monroe

Sen. Bruce Starr

Witnesses Present: Sen. Avel Gordly, District 23

Sen. Richard Devlin, District 19

Dr. Melvin Kohn, Department of Human Services, State Epidemiologist

Dr. Jeffrey Fellows, Investigator, Kaiser Permanente Center for

Health Research

John Valley, Government Affairs Director, American Heart

Association; Tobacco-Free Coalition of Oregon

Steven Rowe, Cascade Cigar and Tobacco, Portland

David Nelson, Portland Meadows Racecourse, Portland

Shawn Miller, Oregon Charitable Gaming Association, Beaverton

Jack Elder, Oregon Charitable Gaming Association, Beaverton

Bill Perry, Oregon Restaurant Association

Phil Donovan, Govt. Affairs Representative, American Heart Association

 

Staff Present: Paul Warner, Legislative Revenue Officer

Mazen Malik, Economist

Barbara Guardino, Committee Assistant

 

 

TAPE 110, SIDE A

004

Chair Deckert

Calls meeting to order at 8:52 a.m. Opens public hearing on SB 571-A.

 

PUBLIC HEARING, SB 571-A

 

013

Malik

Mazen Malik, Economist (Exhibits A E)

023

Chair Deckert

 

024

Malik

 

025

Chair Deckert

 

027

Malik

 

029

Chair Deckert

 

032

Sen. Burdick

 

034

Malik

 

039

Sen. Burdick

 

040

Malik

 

045

Chair Deckert

 

046

Sen. Burdick

 

050

Chair Deckert

 

052

Sen. Burdick

 

075

Chair Deckert

 

080

Sen. Gordly

Sen. Avel Gordly, District 23

109

Chair Deckert

 

112

Sen. Devlin

Sen. Richard Devlin, District 19

170

Sen. Starr

 

178

Sen. Devlin

 

190

Chair Deckert

 

195

Malik

Exhibits F, G and H

 

TAPE 111, SIDE A

001

Malik

 

128

Chair Deckert

 

129

Malik

Exhibit I

261

Chair Deckert

 

278

Kohn

Dr. Melvin Kohn, Department of Human Services, State Epidemiologist (Exhibit J)

360

Sen. Burdick

 

367

Kohn

 

375

Chair Deckert

 

382

Kohn

 

389

Chair Deckert

 

406

Kohn

 

409

Chair Deckert

 

413

Fellows

Dr. Jeffrey Fellows, Investigator, Kaiser Permanente Center for Health Research (Exhibit K)

 

TAPE 110, SIDE B

001

Fellows

 

121

Vice Chair George

 

125

Fellows

 

202

Chair Deckert

 

208

Valley

John Valley, Government Affairs Director, American Heart Association; Tobacco-Free Coalition of Oregon (Exhibit L)

322

Chair Deckert

 

325

Sen. Starr

 

337

Kohn

 

365

Sen. Starr

 

372

Kohn

 

377

Fellows

 

433

Chair Deckert

 

447

Valley

 

488

Chair Deckert

 

 

 

 

TAPE 111, SIDE B

029

Valley

 

054

Chair Deckert

 

055

Sen. Burdick

 

056

Chair Deckert

 

066

Sen. Monroe

 

067

Chair Deckert

 

074

Rowe

Steven Rowe, Cascade Cigar and Tobacco, Portland

137

Chair Deckert

 

139

Nelson

David Nelson, Portland Meadows Racecourse, Portland

176

Chair Deckert

 

178

Miller

Shawn Miller, Oregon Charitable Gaming Association, Beaverton

218

Chair Deckert

 

219

Elder

Jack Elder, Oregon Charitable Gaming Association (Exhibit M)

237

Perry

Bill Perry, Oregon Restaurant Association

274

Chair Deckert

 

276

Vice Chair George

 

287

Elder

 

296

Perry

 

314

Chair Deckert

 

322

Perry

 

330

Chair Deckert

 

333

Sen. Starr

 

355

Perry

 

362

Chair Deckert

 

364

Sen. Starr

 

370

Chair Deckert

 

377

Donovan

Phil Donovan, Govt. Affairs Representative, American Heart Association

433

Chair Deckert

Closes public hearing on SB 571-A. Recesses meeting at 10:40 a.m.

 

TAPE 112, SIDE A

WORK SESSION, SB 571-A

 

003

Chair Deckert

Reconvenes meeting at 10:50 a.m. Opens work session on SB 571-A.

021

Sen. Burdick

 

022

Chair Deckert

 

031

Sen. Burdick

 

042

Chair Deckert

 

044

Sen. Starr

MOTION: MOVED ADOPTION OF SB 571-A15 AMENDMENTS WITH A CONCEPTUAL AMENDMENT ON LINE 12, PAGE 2

048

Chair Deckert

 

051

Sen. Starr

 

076

Chair Deckert

 

089

Vice Chair George

 

096

Chair Deckert

ORDER: ROLL CALL VOTE: MOTION PASSED 3-2-0

VOTING AYE: GEORGE, STARR, DECKERT

VOTING NO: BURDICK, MONROE

108

Vice Chair George

 

113

Chair Deckert

 

121

Vice Chair George

 

124

Sen. Starr

MOTION: MOVED ADOPTION OF SB 571-A13 AMENDMENTS

125

Chair Deckert

 

130

Sen. Monroe

 

151

Chair Deckert

 

154

Sen. Burdick

 

165

Chair Deckert

 

166

Vice Chair George

 

168

Sen. Monroe

 

170

Chair Deckert

Recesses at 11:00; reconvenes at 11:05 in order to recess until 2:00 p.m.

 

RECONVENES MEETING AT 2:00 P.M. IN HEARING ROOM 50

 

 

 

TAPE 113, SIDE A

 

001

Chair Deckert

Reconvenes meeting at 2:11 p.m. Continues work session on SB 571-A.

005

Sen. Starr

 

010

Chair Deckert

Recesses at 2:13 p.m.

011

Chair Deckert

Reconvenes the meeting at 2:15 p.m. Motion on the table is adoption of SB 571-A13 amendments.

 

013

Chair Deckert

ORDER: ROLL CALL VOTE: MOTION PASSED 3-2-0

VOTING AYE: GEORGE, MONROE, STARR

VOTING NO: BURDICK, DECKERT

 

021

Sen. Monroe

MOTION: MOVED SB 571-A AS AMENDED TO THE SENATE FLOOR WITH A DO PASS RECOMMENDATION

023

Sen. Deckert

 

025

Sen. Starr

 

033

Chair Deckert

 

035

Sen. Monroe

Withdraws the motion

037

Chair Deckert

 

038

Sen. Starr

MOTION: MOVED ADOPTION OF SB 571-A14 AMENDMENTS

047

Chair Deckert

 

049

Sen. Monroe

 

059

Chair Deckert

 

060

Vice Chair George

 

069

Chair Deckert

ORDER: ROLL CALL VOTE: MOTION FAILED 2-3-0

VOTING AYE: GEORGE, STARR,

VOTING NO: BURDICK, MONROE, DECKERT

 

076

Sen. Monroe

MOTION: MOVED SB 571-A AS AMENDED TO THE SENATE FLOOR WITH A DO PASS RECOMMENDATION

077

Chair Deckert

 

079

Vice Chair George

 

080

Deckert

 

084

Sen. Starr

 

111

Chair Deckert

 

112

Sen. Monroe

 

123

Chair Deckert

 

138

Sen. Burdick

 

142

Chair Deckert

ORDER: ROLL CALL VOTE: MOPTION PASSED 3-2-0

VOTING AYE: COURTNEY, MONROE, DECKERT

VOTING NO: GEORGE, STARR

149

Sen. Starr

 

 

152

Chair Deckert

Closes work session on SB 517-A. Adjourns the meeting at 2:25 p.m.

 

Tape Index Submitted by:

 

 

 

 

 

Barbara J. Guardino, Committee Assistant

 

 

 

 

Exhibit Summary:

  1. SB 571-A11 proposed amendments, 4/24/07, Charitable Gaming Association
  2. SB 571-A13 proposed amendments, 5/2/07, Portland Meadows
  3. SB 571-A14 proposed amendments, 5/4/07, Charitable Gaming Association
  4. SB 571-A15 proposed amendments, 5/4/07, Burdick
  5. SB 571-A16 proposed amendments, 5/4/07, Burdick
  6. SB 571-A, Revenue Impact of Proposed Legislation, 4/11/07, Malik
  7. SB 571-A, Staff Measure Summary, Senate Committee on Judiciary, 3/21/07, Malik
  8. SB 571-A, Smoke Free Workplace Restrictions, PowerPoint slide show, 5/7/07, Malik
  9. SB 571-A, Papers: Effect of smoke-free workplaces on smoking behaviour, 6 March, 2007, Malik
  10. SB 571-A, testimony of Melvin Kohn, MD, State Epidemiologist, 5/7/07
  11. SB 571-A, testimony from Jeffrey L. Fellows, Kaiser Permanente Center for Health Research, 5/7/07
  12. SB 571-A, testimony of John Valley, American Heart Association, 5/7/07
  13. SB 571-A, testimony of Jack Elder, chairman, Oregon Charitable Gaming Association, 5/7/07